getfast New Reader
Dec. 14, 2010 11:24 a.m.

Hey guys, I'm trying to figure out a weird noise that my beater '95 325i is making, please help.

I have not heard this particular noise before on any of the dozens of E30/E36 cars I've been around over the years, it's been doing it for at least a thousand miles now and it's not getting any quieter.

It's definitely a whirrrr or whine (not a rattle), it sounds kinda like a supercharger or the start of a bad power steering pump.

It whines the worst when the engine is idling and the clutch pedal is pushed to the floor and the car is not moving, whether it's in gear or not.

Conversely the whine is most quiet when the engine is idling and the clutch is disengaged and the car is not in gear and not moving.

Then it makes the whine when the clutch is used and during acceleration through the lower part of the rev range, especially in 1st and 2nd. Reach a certain rpm - like somewhere around 2500 - and the noise goes away. At highway speeds/revs I can't hear it at all.

There is no vibration and no clunking going into any gears, the clutch slips a bit (but doesn't chatter) and the car shifts fine otherwise (but does have the usual sloppy shifter.)

Its pitch changes with engine speed, not wheel speed (ruling out a diff or driveshaft issue?)

Bimmerforums suggests transmission input shaft bearing, but isn't the input shaft not spinning when the clutch is engaged and the car is not in gear and not moving (i.e. when the noise is the loudest?)

Doesn't a bad release bearing just chatter/rattle, not whine (and only make noise when it's disengaged)? How about a bad pilot bearing, could that be the culprit?

I'm mostly curious because the car is getting a new clutch soon, and I'm in the assembling-of-parts stage now. I'd like to do the job once and forget about it.

Many thanks for your thoughts,

Jon (ps- I may be able to post some video later today if the above description is unclear)

93celicaGT2 SuperDork
Dec. 14, 2010 11:25 a.m.

I'm actually with Bimmerforums on this one, but i'm no expert.

Dec. 14, 2010 11:30 a.m.

Input shaft bearing it is.

Check the fluid in your gearbox - the way this usually happens is that either the front or rear seal leaks and eventually the level in the gearbox leaves the front bearing dry (its the highest point compared to the sump).

tuna55 Dork
Dec. 14, 2010 11:34 a.m.

Sounds like a transmission bearing. It only makes it at low speeds because that's when you're really imparting a side load on the gears themselves. In fourth or fifth just cruising I'll bet it's silent. Check the fluid, but it's probably shot. Bearings are really cheap, though, for just about any manual tranny. Putting them in, however, is not trivial.

getfast New Reader
Dec. 14, 2010 11:41 a.m.

Thanks guys! That's exactly what I was hoping to avoid - having to take the gearbox apart to deal with this bearing.

There's enough fluid splatter underneath that I can't really tell what's what. The car has a semi-unknown history, for all I know the trans fluid has 139k miles on it now.

Dec. 14, 2010 11:51 a.m.
getfast wrote: It whines the worst when the engine is idling and the clutch pedal is pushed to the floor and the car is not moving, whether it's in gear or not.

DOH. I should have read that a little closer. Yeah. The input shaft won't be turning with the car in gear and the clutch depressed. I somehow read it as "loudest in neutral with the clutch released".

It could just be the TO bearing - they usually rattle but they do have a roller bearing in the face against the clutch fingers.

getfast New Reader
Dec. 14, 2010 2:16 p.m.

Thanks for the clarification. Sure hoping it's that and not something inside the transmission - not trying to spend any more money than is absolutely necessary, also trying to knock out the clutch job in half a day or less

That said... release bearing, pilot bearing, pivot pin, spring clip, seals, etc are all getting replaced during the clutch job. Sure I could find a good used trans for a few hundred bucks but see above, this is a beater.

tuna55 Dork
Dec. 14, 2010 2:48 p.m.
Giant Purple Snorklewacker wrote:
getfast wrote: It whines the worst when the engine is idling and the clutch pedal is pushed to the floor and the car is not moving, whether it's in gear or not.

DOH. I should have read that a little closer. Yeah. The input shaft won't be turning with the car in gear and the clutch depressed. I somehow read it as "loudest in neutral with the clutch released".

It could just be the TO bearing - they usually rattle but they do have a roller bearing in the face against the clutch fingers.

Yup - didn't catch that either.

getfast New Reader
Dec. 14, 2010 10:56 p.m.

Well the good news is that a local E36 guru thinks it's "definitely clutch related, not internal " after a test-drive.

The bad news is that the $100 old-but-new-in-box clutch kit I went to get from a buddy turned out to be for an E30.

7pilot Reader
Dec. 15, 2010 7:46 a.m.

Hearing the noise when you depress the clutch pedal....Clutch release bearing. It starts as a whirr, gets louder, then you start to feel the fine vibration in the clutch pedal when it is depressed the the ambient temps lower.

m

You'll need to log in to post.

Also on Grassroots Motorsports

Rapid Transit BMW: Meet an Early 5-Series With a V8 Swap

5 hours ago in Articles

Killing a Butterfly With a Sledgehammer

You Need This: SEMA Show CRZ

5 hours ago in News

If green paint and big speakers are your thing, you've come to the right place.

Deal of the Month: Christmas in July!

6 hours ago in News

Get a year of our magazine for just $10.

Tech Tips: 2006–’15 Mazda MX-5

1 day ago in Articles

We asked a couple experts for the best way to upgrade the NC MX-5.

Project Turbo Miata: Hitting the Dyno With a Fresh Engine

1 day ago in Project Cars

After getting a new engine, our turbo Miata project rolled onto the dyno.

Reader's Ride of the Week: Proud Prius

1 day ago in News

Paul Sexton takes the checker while staying green.

Your Projects: Throwback MR2

1 day ago in News

Take a Toyota MR2 AW11, add mud flaps and a cool livery, and you're ready for rallycross.

You Need This: Wacky Mazda RX-8

1 day ago in News

Out with the rotary and in with the luxurious Infiniti drivetrain.

From the GRM Vault: Subaru Bounces Back

4 days ago in Articles

Proof that motorsports involvement can lead to corporate success.

Your Projects: SkinnyG's V8 Pontiac Firefly

4 days ago in News

Talk about a sleeper.

Calling All LS-Powered Track Machines to Holley LS Fest

4 days ago in News

Holley LS Fest will once again feature the Grassroots Motorsports Road Course Challenge.

From the GRM Vault: A Dual-Engine Honda CRX and 10 Other Cool Cars Hit the Dyno

5 days ago in Articles

Back in 1997 we put 11 cool cars on the dyno in search of horsepower and truth.

OUR SPONSORS

Grassroots Motorsports Magazine

Subscribe Today

Also get your instant access to the digital edition of Grassroots Motorsports Magazine!

Learn More
5uKhoBxp7Iokh95UorDmhzvZgNDYGlnR