Last year we bought a new 2011 Foreman 4x4 with electric shift. This was after our 25 year old Honda Fourtrax 250 finally bit the dust. The electric shift was mainly for my wife, but it does work well. If it ever goes out there is an emergency shift lever you can use which is stored under the seat. When/if it does go out it's usually a simple solenoid iirc.
I do not like Honda cars. That being said I like their powersports division. The atvs are pretty bulletproof and even though the Foreman is a utility quad it can be fun.
The Foreman is underpowered compared to pretty much any other atv in that class, but the power is adequate and because of such mild tuning the engine should last a long time.
The pre 2012 Foremans are VERY simple. Single cylinder, air cooled, carb, solid rear axle, drum brake rear.
I use mine primarily on our property to check the fence line, move cars around, and pull small trailers. if you'll be doing things like that you definitely want 4x4...it helps a lot to get the load moving. We've also used it camping and riding at offroad parks, with jumps, mud, you name it. It really is a great all around atv.
The main reason I bought the Foreman was because of the transmission....it is one of the last utility atvs you can get without CVT.....and I hate CVT, so it really came down to the Foreman or the Honda Rubicon, which has a different transmission (with full auto mode), but still not CVT. The Rubicon almost won out, but in the end I was looking for simplicity and a long life and I felt the Foreman would do everything I need and hopefully last another 25 years.
BTW We started looking at used ATVs.....2004 and up. The good ones hold their value so well we ended up shopping dealers and getting a great deal on a new one.
BTW again....ours tops at right around 55mph.....I think it squeaked to 56-57 once.