I went to my local independent tire guy (Radial Tire Company in Silver Spring MD - they're race tire experts, can shave tires, and generally beat tire rack once labor is factored in) and asked Paul, the owner what he liked for my 2WD Tacoma SR5 Pre-Runner which takes a 265/70-16. He asked how long I intended to keep it, his rationale being that the if I were to keep it another 75k or better he'd recommend Michelin LTX A/T2s which would be a bit under $800/set out the door. If I wasn't keeping it that long he'd recommend something cheaper and less long wearing.
Considering that I've never said "You know, I really wish I hadn't bought such good tires..." I threw down for the Michelins and was very favorably impressed during the snowmageddon, snowpocolypse, brutal-snow-laden-winter-of-our-discontent.
A bit spendy but it drives like a new truck, has good dry, wet and snowy grip and nice road manners. And they're supposed to wear like iron.