I was just on my local CL and was surprised to see 2 cars listed for nearly the same price ($5500 + or - a few bucks). But then again, big bucks luxo sedan lose so much in depreciation...
A 2000 "New" Beetle and a 1999 Jag XJ8. Consider the "demographics" of the local population, I imagine that the Jag is already gone and the Beetle sits for a long time.
Consider the reps of both manufacturers, I'm not sure either would be a bargain.

