NickD
NickD Dork
10/22/16 11:53 a.m.

Not entirely new, I guess, as they were actually originally built in 1942 (2 prototypes) and and 1945-1946 (50 main productions models) but a new one is currently being built. What is "they"? Well, just one of the craziest, most advanced, fastest steam locomotives to ever ply the U.S. railroads: The Pennsylvania T-1 "duplex"

A small bit of a history lesson, as I'm sure aren't familiar with these things. Headed into the '40s, the Pennsylvania Railroad realized that they hadn't built a new passenger locomotive since the end of the K-series 4-6-2 Pacifics, a series of locomotives that had started in 1914 and ended in '28. Trains were getting longer and heavier and the Pennsy was finding themselves doubling up K4s on the head of their trains, which wasn't efficient or economic.

So the PRR called up Baldwin Locomotive Works, who were kind of the mad scientist of locomotive designs, and gave them a performance bogey and set them loose. This was a radical departure for the time as the PRR was usually conservative in their locomotive designs and was big on building their own locomotives at their Juniata shops.

The result was the T-1 which was based on Baldwin's experimentation with "duplex" locomotives. This designs split the locomotive's driving wheels into two sets, each with its own pair of cylinders and rods. Traditionally, the only locomotives with two sets of drivers were articulated locomotives, but the T-1 used one rigid frame. In a duplex design, cylinders could be smaller and the weight of side and main rods could be drastically reduced. Given that the movement of the main rod could not be fully balanced, the duplex design would reduce "hammer blow" on the track. The lower reciprocating mass meant that higher speeds could be achieved, and there are reports of T-1s operating at over 120mph during passenger service. They were also styled by famed industrial designer Raymond Loewy, making them very distinctive with their sharknose cowling.

Unfortunately, they were plagued with issues. One was that they were so massively powerful, that they were plagued with slippage even once they had a train moving, they just made more power than they could put to the rails effectively. This was also exacerbated by a design issue on the early units which tied the front and rear "engines" together on their suspension and would cause the front wheels to lift on a curve. Slipping the wheels for extended periods also had a tendency to bust up the experimental (And fragile) rotary cam valve gear. A big portion was that engineers were not trained properly for operating them and tried to operate them as a conventional locomotive, and tended to be a bit too "generous" with the throttle. They were also expensive, difficult to maintain and arrived late in the era of steam. Steam locomotive development was winding down and dieselization was starting. So by 1956, the PRR had retired and scrapped every last one of them.

So, where is this going? Well, the T1 Trust, a private organization, has decided that that was a crime against humanity and has started to construct a brand-new, from the ground up, Pennsylvania T1 that will be 100% operational, while fixing some of the original design issues. I originally kind of dismissed it as a bit of a pipe dream, but after reading an interview with Trains these people seem to be going in with realistic expectations ($10 million budget, 2030 completion date) and appear to be pretty well organized. They have already started construction, having built a new number plate and headlight, cast a set of driving wheels and found a surviving rotary cam valve gear setup to document and recreate, as well as working on getting a place to operate it. They also give solid reasons why they aren't restoring an existing locomotive.

I don't expect everyone to get all geeked out by this like I am, but you have to be impressed at the scale of such a project and the logistics of building something that the industry doesn't even exist to do anymore. I don't think any of us are allowed to complain about fixing up a rusty car anymore, in light of this.

NickD
NickD Dork
10/22/16 12:38 p.m.

https://www.youtube.com/embed/ihCHzS4jT_M

Some rare old 8mm footage of T1s in operation. You can see the wheelslip issue in a couple spot.

1988RedT2
1988RedT2 PowerDork
10/22/16 12:45 p.m.

Very cool. Good to see another railroad enthusiast on here. If you find yourself in Roanoke, VA, be sure to check out the Virginia Transportation Museum, which has a nice collection of steam locos, including N & W #611, due back from NC on October 24th.

I think the J-Class was probably the pinnacle of steam locomotive design that saw extensive service through 1959.

http://fireup611.org/about-611/

Also, be sure to get to the O. Winston Link museum!

NickD
NickD Dork
10/22/16 12:53 p.m.

I would not argue with the J-series, simply because it was powerful and reliable but it was a relatively traditional construction. The T1 was likely one of the innovative and advanced engines designed, so I would consider it the pinnacle in that regard.

I haven't been to Roanoke, but I did go to Steamtown again recently (pretty depressing place, honestly and I still have yet to ride behind a big road locomotive there) and I went to Strasburg years ago (Which is phenomenal) I am hoping to see Reading #2102 next year when that returns to service and supposedly a big C&0 Allegheny #1309 is going to be up and running next year.

Keep hoping that the PRR K-4 #1361 will one day get finished, as I'm a big PRR fan. Funny, because I had family that worked for New York Central and New York, Ontario & Western, so Pennsy was kind of the enemy, but their equipment just always looked right to me.

1988RedT2
1988RedT2 PowerDork
10/22/16 12:57 p.m.

Agree with you on Steamtown as well as on Strasburg. Been to both twice. Strasburg is like stepping back in time, with steam trains chugging past the small neat Amish farms surrounding the area.

NickD
NickD Dork
10/22/16 1:05 p.m.

I hadn't been to Steamtown in like 17 years. Went back last month, they no longer do the shop tours, there is no large steam locomotives operational to do excursions, the stuff sitting outside has deteriorated pretty badly (CN #47 stands out in particular) and just a general feeling of a lot of history wasting away.

Strasburg the staff is friendly (My father and I went on a rainy day and we basically got a private shop tour and they took us up in the cabs of the locomotives and showed us stuff usually not on the tour) and the care for the equipment is obvious, everything is pristine and well-maintained and you can tell they aren't on the shoestring budget that Steamtown is.

Gearheadotaku
Gearheadotaku GRM+ Memberand PowerDork
10/27/16 5:53 p.m.

I've always found steam locomotives fascinating. Its like a 400 ton swiss watch.

akamcfly
akamcfly Dork
10/27/16 8:37 p.m.

link

A former coworker did this a couple times and loved the experience.

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners
oL4nIdq7rVLKPvJZbIgQlqbhAe7eWlbc4zxKoU1KPTHmx3nviR7BN6V2iRba6Kcp