How to choose the right tools for cutting metal

By Carl Heideman
Apr 28, 2024 | Tools, metal, Shop Work, cutting | Posted in Shop Work | From the Oct. 2009 issue | Never miss an article

Photography by Carl Heideman • Lead photograph courtesy Tekton/Unsplash

[Editor's Note: This article originally appeared in the October 2009 issue of Grassroots Motorsports.]

A big part of being grassroots involves making things out of metal: brackets, supports, bearing holders, levers and more. Sometimes you’re making things from scratch; other times you’re modifying a part from one application to fit another. No matter what the task, one way or another you’re going to have to cut that metal to size. 

However, there’s more than one way to tackle the job, and each method has its pluses and minuses. Some are faster, some are quieter, and some offer a little more precision. The trick is matching the right tool to the task at hand.

Aviation Shears

Compound “aviation” shears are great for cutting sheet metal, including steel, aluminum and stainless. Unfortunately, these tools are misunderstood. They’re designed to trim no more than a quarter of an inch of material from the edge of a panel. These clippers curl the waste to one side, so attacking too much material hurts accuracy.

To use them correctly, first make a rough cut with another tool. Then use the snips to get within a few thousandths of an inch of your cut line. The waste will curl away, while the remaining panel will stay smooth.

When shopping for these clippers, you’ll notice red, green and yellow handles. The yellow cutters are for straight cuts, red for left cuts, and green for right cuts. Since the red and green clippers can handle straight cuts as well, just pick up those two. We also strongly recommend staying with one of the brand names. 


A good old hacksaw offers a quick, easy way to make straight cuts in smaller pieces of metal, like tubing and small stock. Longer cuts take a lot of time and muscle, and accuracy can be an issue. Nonetheless, this is a must-have tool for every fabricator.

Air-Powered or Electric Die Grinder With 3-inch Cutoff Wheel

Despite the downsides, a die grinder with a cutoff wheel is a versatile tool. Where the aviation snips are perfect for thin sheet metal, the cutoff wheel works very well with thicker materials. If you have a good compressor, go for an air-operated unit; its small size and light weight will make it more maneuverable in tight spaces. 

While a die grinder can technically handle very thick metal, we find that they’re best when tackling stock of up to 3/16 inch thick. After that, the cutting slows significantly—that’s your sign to move to something more powerful.

When shopping for the cutoff wheels, stick to a name brand—we prefer 3M. Since these wheels can spin upward of 20,000 rpm, we don’t recommend the offshore imitation pieces. 

Expect to pay a fair price for quality cutoff wheels.

We also prefer very thin wheels, as they make a narrower, faster cut. Most stores stock the 1/16-inch-thick wheels, but they’ll usually welcome orders for the 1/32-inch wheels. 

Die grinders cut straight lines very well and can easily be used for large-radius curves. For small-radius curves, they can work in a pinch. However, they’ll waste a lot of material. Finally, even though an air-powered muffler cutter can cut through similar materials, stick to a real die grinder.

Hole Saw

If you have to cut a large hole, a hole saw will do the job quickly and easily. However, size matters: You’ll need a pretty powerful drill to create holes of 2 inches in diameter or larger. When possible, we prefer using a drill press with our hole saws.

Angle Grinder, 4-Inch or Larger

An electric angle grinder can make quick work of medium-thick metal. We usually use a 41/2-inch model.

Just like die grinders, an angle grinder does a good job on straight and large-radius cuts. Detail cuts are possible, but they’ll waste a lot of material. 

We also recommend sticking with good, name-brand cutting wheels. These grinders pack a lot of power, and a shattered wheel is going to hurt someone.

Horizontal Bandsaw

If you’re working with square or round tubing, the horizontal bandsaw is your best friend. It can quickly cut material with great accuracy. 

While budget models are out there, it’s better to step up to at least a midrange unit. These machines will have stout clamps that can be accurately adjusted for miter joints. Additionally, the higher-end models feature coolant/lubricant pump systems that speed up the work while extending blade life.

Vertical Bandsaw

Like the horizontal bandsaw, a good vertical bandsaw is a wonderful tool for the serious fabricator. Unfortunately, good machines are expensive, and the lower-cost units can be disappointing.

A high-quality model will feature a variable speed drive, a large depth, and a blade welder to help fit blades to that particular machine. Avoid the temptation to use a unit designed for wood—most can’t run slowly enough to cut metal, and frustration will ensue. If you’re lucky enough to end up with a good machine, you’ll be rewarded with the ability to quickly cut brackets and other parts to very accurate sizes and shapes.

Oxy/Acetylene Torch

While it’s undoubtedly cool to cut metal with fire, we use a torch as a last resort. Between the fire risks, lack of accuracy, and need to clean up the cuts with a grinder, we save the torching for when we need to make rough cuts or are working with very thick metal. 

While we don’t often use the torch for cutting, it’s a great tool for heating rusted fasteners and, of course, welding. We use a budget-priced portable unit.

Plasma Cutter

The plasma cutter represents the best way to cut metal with fire. These units can create some pretty accurate cuts, especially if a guide is used. Like the oxy/acetylene torch, the plasma cutter’s cuts require some cleanup. 

Reciprocating Saw

If you spend a lot of time at the local pick-’n-pull, a cordless reciprocating saw is a wonderful asset: Just cut out the section you need and drag it home. This tool can also be used to cut away offending sections so you can get to the parts that you need. We have even cut entire cars into pieces with these units. Everyone needs a reciprocating saw in their arsenal.

We use ours as a rough-cutting tool. When it’s time for accuracy, other tools do it better.

Sabre Saw

We’ve been using a Black & Decker sabre saw for more than 20 years now, and we’ve probably voided the warranty a million times. These versatile units work like vertical bandsaws; they’re just less glamorous.

The biggest problem with this tool is that it vibrates the piece being cut. We try to use a lot of clamps to keep this issue at bay. Nonetheless, these tools are great for budget fabricators.

Chop Saw

If you can’t afford a horizontal bandsaw or don’t have space for one, a chop saw is the next best thing. While it doesn’t cut as accurately, it comes close—figure on being within 1/16 inch of your mark.

Join Free Join our community to easily find more Tools, metal, Shop Work and cutting articles.
Vigo (Forum Supporter)
Vigo (Forum Supporter) MegaDork
10/22/20 9:32 a.m.

I have finally learned what the name (and 'actual purpose'?) for this thing is!

I came up in the southwest in an era when almost all factory exhaust pieces were stainless anyway, so if cutting mufflers was ever a common thing, i missed it.. I think i've owned one or several of these tips for most of my adult life, though. 

APEowner GRM+ Memberand Dork
10/22/20 10:15 a.m.
Vigo (Forum Supporter) said:

I have finally learned what the name (and 'actual purpose'?) for this thing is!

I came up in the southwest in an era when almost all factory exhaust pieces were stainless anyway, so if cutting mufflers was ever a common thing, i missed it.. I think i've owned one or several of these tips for most of my adult life, though.

I grew up in the Northeast in the heart of the rust belt when exhaust systems were mild steel.  Cutting parts of exhaust systems was definitely a thing and I used those so much that I've worn them out. However, the oxy/acetylene torch is my preferred weapon of choice for exhaust work.  In some circumstances and in the right hands it can actually be the most precise tool. 

Because it won't cut until the metal reaches a certain temperature and there's a natural thermal break between two components it's possible to cut away one part that's in contact with another with minimal to no damage to the adjoining part. 

For example you can cut an outer pipe off an inner or vise versa.  You can also cut a nut off a bolt without damaging the bolt.  I've even cut king pins out of truck axles with the torch.

paddygarcia GRM+ Memberand New Reader
10/22/20 12:33 p.m.

I've been getting pretty good results with the combination of a Milwaukee portaband saw and a Swag Offroad stand. Won't do anything big but for angles, square, and probably round stock it's very handy. 

billstewartx New Reader
8/17/21 3:33 p.m.

Jump Shear??  

twentyover GRM+ Memberand Dork
8/17/21 10:00 p.m.

Beverly Shear?

Pete. (l33t FS)
Pete. (l33t FS) GRM+ Memberand MegaDork
3/18/23 11:51 a.m.


is my new best friend.

It cuts sheetmetal WAY faster, quieter, and more accurately than any other method I have.

I wish I had this a year ago.

BimmerMaven Reader
11/5/23 2:38 p.m.

surprised that there was no mention of a(slow blade speed) 14" Carbide chop saw.   clean, fast, cool cuts that are true and ready to weld.


it can also shave off tiny slivers to fine-tune length.   the abrasive chop blades just deflect.



the torch and plasma cutters take practice and a steady height and travel speed to make a clean cut.   when machine-controlled, the edges are remarkable.



remember that high pressure, low speed, and CUTTING oil are the rule for toothed hi-speed steel blades.    high pressure means chips or curls.   low pressure and high speed will overheat the tips of the teeth....instantly dulling them.   ditto for drill bits.

yupididit GRM+ Memberand UltimaDork
11/5/23 3:01 p.m.

In reply to Pete. (l33t FS) :

What is that? 


gixxeropa GRM+ Memberand Reader
11/5/23 3:39 p.m.

In reply to yupididit :

Milwaukee m12 nibbler I believe

Pete. (l33t FS)
Pete. (l33t FS) GRM+ Memberand MegaDork
11/5/23 3:50 p.m.

In reply to gixxeropa :


Also known as the machine that goes BZZRP through sheetmetal like it was nothing.

I usually use it on the lowest speed, because like any really good power tool, it can also make mistakes really fast too.

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners