1 2
dj06482 (Forum Supporter)
dj06482 (Forum Supporter) GRM+ Memberand UltraDork
8/2/22 10:48 p.m.

Our minivan was a similar story. We bought a '17 Odyssey in 2020 with 193k on it (not a misprint). I ran the math, and where we got it, it was a solid deal where we could afford to replace one major component (engine or transmission) and still be ahead of the game compared to a lower mileage one. And if I needed to replace something, it was going in a late model car, not one of my ancient clunkers. Plus, owning something that's already taken a major depreciation hit limits the potential future loss from a depreciation perspective.

It had no records with it, but was in excellent shape, likely used as an airport shuttle for three years and traded in. I figured if someone relied on it for income, they likely took care of it. I did the timing belt right away (again, no records), along with some other maintenance stuff. Started driving it in earnest, and it started flashing transmission codes. Took it to the dealer we bought it from, and they replaced the transmission with a used one that slipped from the get go. Took it back to the dealer, and after a fight, they put in a second used transmission. It was a fight, but all of this was covered by the state-mandated used car warranty.

After the second transmission replacement, I was tempted to call the experiment a failure and cut bait. But I figured that I could still replace a major component and come out ahead. So I've done some preventative maintenance (replaced the radiator, transmission lines that had been leaking, installed an aftermarket transmission cooler, changed the AT filter, and perform regular drains/fills of the ATF), and just started driving it (albeit with a tote full of tools and a good scanner in it).


Long story short, I've built some confidence in the car that I formerly didn't trust and life is better. We've taken it down to FL with the entire family and all our gear, and it handled it with ease. I have enough cash parked in my emergency car repair fund that if something major goes south, I'm covered. Did the Blackstone Labs oil analysis on the motor, and it came back clean.

I'd have an oil analysis done on your truck to see if it picks up anything obvious, and go from there. You're probably frustrated between your dealer experience and the repairs it's needed, so sometimes it helps to take a step back and assess the entire situation.  In my case, it was worth it to roll the dice for an amount of time to see how it worked out.

Paul_VR6 (Forum Supporter)
Paul_VR6 (Forum Supporter) SuperDork
8/3/22 8:39 a.m.

I had a Land Rover once and I didn't feel bad when I sold it cool

I think this one is a case of the devil you know is likely better than the devil you don't. Fix the lingering thing that is bothering you and run it into the ground.

93gsxturbo
93gsxturbo UltraDork
8/3/22 12:56 p.m.

If you don't like it now after spending a pile of money on it, get rid of it and take the L.  Consider the money and time spent to be a valuable education in doing due diligence prior to purchase.  

 

NY Nick
NY Nick GRM+ Memberand Dork
8/3/22 1:16 p.m.

In reply to 93gsxturbo :

That's where I'm at. It just pisses me off every time I look at it so it's got to go. I have had a few days to think this one over. I've owned a lot of vehicles, like 15-20. I've done ok with most of them. Some of them I've made decent money on. This one I got hurt. It's like going to the casino. People only want to think about the wins. Well the house took this one, I'm gonna cash out what's left of my pile and play a different day. I'll tell the potential buyer everything and leave with a clean conscious. 

SV reX
SV reX MegaDork
8/3/22 5:25 p.m.

There is a difference between being HONEST and being OPEN and OVER-SHARING.

You should never be dishonest in a response. 
 

You are not obligated to volunteer information. That one is tough for some people, but it is the essence of caveat emptor.  
 

When you give information, don't give too much. Every little detail and concern about anything and everything that might potentially happen in the future is more info than is needed, and a likely deal killer.

1 2

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners
3FgyOnoCEH0C1TMZglGruCtWnIWPgYAMRUW2Lc16QKVG5EE4l0c834RbTULBFku6