Let's bump this up.
Let's increase the budget, and put more stipulations on here.
Let's say $5-8k, and not against financing.
RWD. Convertible. Small. Enough space for 2 and their stuff, packing light. Still literally driving around most of the US. Needs to get good gas mileage, and be plenty tossable. Don't need luxury, but comfortable is necessary.
I'm coming up with NB Miata, MR-S, Mazdaspeed Miata or NA Miata. (Obviously pay cash for NA.)
The reason i threw the other cars out in the exercise was because they were all too similar to cars i already have. Seemed silly. Go on a road trip, come home, and have something 95% the same as my MX6. What's the point? I realized that i'm probably keeping the MX6 around for the long haul, so let's try something new.
Pros for the MR-S:
I like the interior better. They're newer. They're powered by a corolla motor, so what's going to go wrong? You don't see millions of them a week. They're very light, and as such, feel more powerful than the Miatas. (Barring the MSM)
Cons:
Not as big of an aftermarket. (Problem after the trip.)
Miata:
Well, it's the answer. And i've always wanted an excuse to buy things from Rev9.
Cons: An NA i can pay cash for might not be something i'd want to take across country. NBs that i can finance aren't any cheaper than MR-S, and sometimes more expensive in this area. I don't find the interior quite as comfy. I'm not sure if i would choose an NB over an NA just because of the looks and aesthetic aftermarket, anyways.
Any other suggestions? I will not be racing either of these cars. Would want a unique, responsive, comfy, "baller" summer daily after the trip that could more than hold it's own on some backroad fun. Something that gets noticed. It's anti-grassroots, but aesthetics will play a BIG role in whatever i get down the road.
If there were a site like Rev9autosport for the MR-S, the deal would be DONE. I know it's stupid, i know those little parts are all expensive, but i've always somewhat wanted a car that i COULD get those parts for. I would do a "retro-ized" Miata over time.