tuna55 wrote: I like sticks in my cars, but currently I only own one, and it is road worthy. That being said, though, if you've ever driven a really fast car (like 10's fast) with a hard shifting automatic, it really does work to your advantage. I can also understand how a big turbo would be much happier behind a traditional auto between shifts, but I've never driven a stick car with one to compare for myself. There are places and purposes for each.
You're right on with the turbo comment. Our modified 87 944t is a manual and our 09 Solstice GXP coupe is an auto. The 5 speed auto in the GXP shifts faster and keeps the car on boost...not to mention it is much easier to launch.
while not a performance car, I bought my 2011 Fiesta with the "Powershift" transmission. I was going to go for the 5 spd, since that is what I have driven for years. After getting a chance to try the PS all by myself, no salesman nanny and doing some internet research , that changed my mine. OK, it doesn't have shift paddles but Ford has programmed some interesting shift patterns. Particularly with the shift lever in the L position. I like it..
To me, regardless of how smooth a newer automatic is or how much of a performance advantage the "manumatics" might give, etc, etc...a nice shifting old fashion manual is just more fun for me. On the streets, I'm not worried if I could shave tenths of a second off my shift time with a paddle shifter, I just want to enjoy my drive. My NC Miata's gearbox puts a smile on my face every time, and it's got 3 pedals. Cool thing for me is that even my wife drives manuals and enjoys them.
Most automatics have a manual function now. Even my Kia Sedona minivan does. It takes 5-7 seconds to respond to a downshift request, but it's there. Yawn....
After saying that, my DD is a slushbox Volvo brick. Needed a cheap new DD and this was a deal I couldn't pass up. The way I look at it, that just makes it all the better when I hop into the Miata.
Klayfish wrote: To me, regardless of how smooth a newer automatic is or how much of a performance advantage the "manumatics" might give, etc, etc...a nice shifting old fashion manual is just more fun for me. On the streets, I'm not worried if I could shave tenths of a second off my shift time with a paddle shifter, I just want to enjoy my drive.
I agree to this.
As for the famed new M3's DSG box, as soon as someone tosses me the keys to one for a test drive, I'll give you my verdict. My birthday is comming up, someone could make it memorable
Something is telling me instant shifting could be hellafun. I'll always own a manual, though there may be room in my garage (once I get a big one) for a twin clutch box.
I was once asked "How Was It" after a run on Deals Gap "The Dragon" I responded "it was pretty good but I was stuck behind a Gold Wing most of the way", the person who asked immediately turned and walked to his..........Gold Wing :-(
Adrian_Thompson wrote:Cotton wrote: Does Ferrari even offer a traditional ( 3 pedal) manual trans in any of their cars these days?Nope, two pedals only these days. Not that I put much value in what Ferrari do or don't sell.
I do.
BOT, auto boxes are rather impressive depending on the vehicle. Big block muscle cars work quite well, luxo barges and worthless crap like Camrys also respond nicely to autos.
You'll need to log in to post.