Keith
Keith GRM+ Memberand SuperDork
5/13/10 7:54 p.m.

The Targa organizers have released the factors for 2010! This is topical to the magazine, as (ahem) there's an article about the Targa Newfoundland in the latest issue I understand

Some background on how the event runs. Each stage is given a base time. Say it's 10 minutes. If you finish the stage in 10 minutes or less, you "zeroed" it. If it takes you longer, then you pick up penalties. The base times get shorter as the event goes on, and nobody finishes without penalties. Easy enough, right?

But there's a twist. Each class has a factor - basically, a handicap. This is done to allow all cars to compete on an even footing. Slower cars get a higher factor. The newest cars with the biggest engines get a factor of 1.000. An older car with a smaller engine and lower modification level might have a factor of 1.100. In this case, the slower car would have 11 minutes to finish the stage without accruing penalties. That's the target time for the stage.

At the end of the race, the car with the fewest penalties wins. Voila. And that's how a BMW 2002 can beat a race-prepped GT-R with Steve Millen behind the wheel (and an overwhelmed journalist in the passenger's seat).

The problem is that it's really hard to handicap the cars well. The older cars benefit from decades of honing in competition - a Mk1 Escort built in 2009 is a much faster car than it was when it was new. The newer cars are getting dramatically faster as electronics play a greater and greater role. And some other cars get caught in the middle.

For 2010, the event's been split in half. The classic cars (30 years old or older) still run the same system as before. There's a new preparation level for the really modified vintage cars that are basically brand new analogue cars under a vintage skin.

But it's the Modern cars that have the big change. Factors have been abolished. It's now down to sheer speed. Got a 1982 Golf GTi? Well, you're up against Steve Millen in a GT-R (and an overwhelmed journalist in the passenger's seat) on an equal footing. The organizers promise an award for the fastest car in each class (1982-1990, 1991-1997, 1998-2004, 2005-present, Hybrid) but there's no split anymore on engine displacement or modification level. There's also an Open class for the real freaks, also on an even footing.

So now it doesn't matter that my 1994 Miata has a 1999 cylinder head, which would put it into Level 3 instead of Level 2 prep level. It's running against anything built from 1991-97 regardless of engine size, factory-fit forced induction, etc. In other words, it's time to go bonkers with the spec sheet and stuff in a V8. There might be some fireworks this year.

The biggest losers in this change are going to be the small cars, particularly those who are novices. Back to how the race works. Every stage has a target time (as we've seen) but also has a "trophy time". This trophy time is something like 40% slower than the target time. If you beat the trophy time on every stage, you win a Targa plate. It's a measure of consistency. If you break, have an off, get lost or otherwise make a whoopsie, you won't get a Targa plate. It's a perfect goal for the novice team - well, after the goal of finishing.

The problem for the small cars now is that the trophy times are based on much more aggressive times. The trophy time for the GT-R is now the same as for the 1982 GTi. Who's going to have to work harder to get that Targa plate? It's unfortunate, as I think that's going to hit the grassroots racers hardest. Still, other than a complex system that's based on the fastest car in a given class, I'm having trouble coming up with a good alternative.

http://www.targanewfoundland.com/news/entry/competition-factors-2010-2014/
http://www.targanewfoundland.com/static/uploads/2010_Factors.pdf

JoeyM
JoeyM GRM+ Memberand HalfDork
5/13/10 8:02 p.m.
Keith wrote: The problem for the small cars now is that the trophy times are based on much more aggressive times. The trophy time for the GT-R is now the same as for the 1982 GTi. Who's going to have to work harder to get that Targa plate? It's unfortunate, as I think that's going to hit the grassroots racers hardest.

This is an understatement

unk577
unk577 New Reader
5/13/10 8:40 p.m.

82 GTI, not in the U.S. Drop an LS motor in and go have some fun. I been dreaming about the Targa once I have my v8r finished.

Streetwiseguy
Streetwiseguy Reader
5/13/10 8:41 p.m.

I understand the need to do something for the newer cars. I read where Millen said he would never go back until the patent unfairness of the rules was addressed- or something a bit more Kiwi with some curse words thrown in.

Maybe the new factor along with your basic GT1-2-3-4-lite theory- Corvettes against Gt-R, GTI against Neon....

Keith
Keith GRM+ Memberand SuperDork
5/14/10 12:12 a.m.

Millen should have brought along an experienced navigator if he really wanted to win, not a terrified journalist. But yes, Stillen (the company) did take their toys home and say they wouldn't come back until the rules worked the way they wanted the rules to work, not the way the rules worked when they read the rule book for the event they entered. Now they do, so it'll be interesting to see if they come back.

From what I understand, the handicapping of Modern cars was done as a bit of an experiment by the organizers. And it didn't work out as hoped. So now the event will work much the same way it does in Tasmania. The change away from Modern factors wasn't a knee-jerk reaction to The Millen Failure To Win, but was undertaken after speaking to a number of experienced competitors. I had some interesting discussions with the rulemakers myself. The rule book for Targa Newfoundland is stable for 5 years at a time (or is it four?), and 2010 is the first year of a new rule "cycle". So if the change was going to be made, this is the year it would happen.

It'll be interesting to see what happens to the entries. There are some complainers on the Targa forum, but they're also complainers who hadn't ever run the race or even entered for this year. Will the small hatchback crowd dry up? Will we see some monsters, and cars taking advantage of a more open rule set? Will people stop being confused as to how the race can be between a vintage 911 and an old 2002 when there are Group B Quattros and a GT-R in the competition?

Appleseed
Appleseed SuperDork
5/14/10 1:40 a.m.

After an explanation of the handicaps, I now understand how a 2002 could win the whole thing. At first I thought that's one mother berkleying fast BMW.

Keith
Keith GRM+ Memberand SuperDork
5/14/10 10:02 a.m.

Yeah, the event didn't make sense without a full explanation of how it worked. Even my boss was telling people it was a TSD while I was at the event!

Don't underestimate how hard that BMW was being run. Sure, it took advantage of the handicaps. But anyone who places in the top 10 was doing it on skill and aggression, not just a well-chosen car with a good handicap. Roy and Adrienne were extracting the full performance out of that car and bringing the specialized knowledge of multiple overall wins of the event. Millen, for example, left quite a bit on the table. Watch some of his videos on YouTube. Millen did a heck of a job going as fast as he did - it's a fast car and he's a very fast driver, but the navigator let the team down and the car really should have been on R-compounds.

Modern cars have come close to winning the whole thing - here's what the results were in 2008 - pretty interesting mix!

1969 BMW 2002
1967 Acadian Canso
2009 Mitsubishi Lancer
1969 Chevrolet Camaro
2008 Subaru WRX Sti 08
2007 Lexus GS 450- Hybrid
1959 Mini

maroon92
maroon92 SuperDork
5/14/10 12:45 p.m.

so...tell me more about this OPEN class....

anything that is street legal?

Keith
Keith GRM+ Memberand SuperDork
5/14/10 1:22 p.m.

Pretty much.

Full ruleset

"This division is intended for competitors who prefer maximum technical freedom for vehicle preparation."

6.13.2 Definition of an Open Division Vehicle Vehicles shall be built on recognized production or semi-production models from recognized manufacturers, incorporating original chassis and body shell.
Tube frame or "silhouette‟ cars are permitted but their entry must be reviewed and approved by the Organizer.
All vehicles shall be built to recognized automotive engineering standards.

6.13.3. Engine
Engines are free.

6.13.4 Exhaust System
The exhaust system is free provided it meets 6.6.
(6.6)
Exhaust pipe(s) shall exit behind the driver and co-driver and external to the body.
Open exhausts are permitted on Targa Stages.
Outside of stages, competitors are requested to drive their vehicles in a manner which minimizes noise.
Specific exhaust and catalytic converter requirements are defined in each of the division definitions listed below.
Vehicles originally equipped with Catalytic Converters must retain functioning Catalytic Converter(s) in their OES location.

6.13.5 Ignition
Ignition systems are free

6.13.6 Fuel Systems
Fuel Systems are free.

6.13.7 Engine Management
Engine Management is free.

6.13.8 Engine Support Systems
Engine Support Systems are free.
Antifreeze should be replaced with water and a water lubricant.

6.13.9 Transmission, Transaxle, Differential, Axles
Drivetrain configuration and components are free.

6.13.10 Chassis
Construction
All Open Division entries must be based on a fixed roof, closed cockpit design.
Chassis modifications are free.
Recognized Automotive Engineering principals shall be used.

Body Panels
Body panels are free.
Aerodynamic aids are free.
When the vehicle is travelling in the forward direction, wheels shall be completely covered by the wheel arches as viewed from above the vehicle.
Wheel arches may be extended.

Windows:
The windshield shall meet DOT standards. Ie: Lexan or similar windshields are not permitted unless OES.
Door, side and rear windows may be made from lexan or similar materials.

Interior
Interior panels are free.

Suspension
Suspension is free.

Steering
Steering is free.

Brakes
Brake Systems are free.

pigeon
pigeon HalfDork
5/14/10 8:24 p.m.

Hol-e-smokes. I'll be interested to see what turns up in the open division - that ruleset is begging for some really wild race cars to show up!

Roy and Adrienne are very talented, and Woodstock (their 2002) is a real grassroots car. I really wish the mag would do an article on them. They are active members of my local BMWCCA chapter and are really great, easy going people, willing to talk and tell stories about the event and the car. I wonder if they're planning to return this year to defend their crown?

Carson
Carson Dork
5/14/10 9:26 p.m.
Keith wrote: Even my boss was telling people it was a TSD while I was at the event!

Wait, what? I thought Janel was up there with you.

maroon92
maroon92 SuperDork
5/14/10 10:57 p.m.

so...what does the benchracer build for Open class?

I am thinking a tubeframe Twincharged LS powered long travel suspension stiff swaybars and a NSX shape.

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners
jCvUhwkuBxIanKwbeEr8fMk5lpPjz5ZR8pGIzc5Ei34kIE9oF8SRb7woopLy9fOF