My wife and I have started having a similar conversation as the OP with similar goals in our location.
I grew up outside of Baltimore. The better suburbs have a lot of what you’re looking for and the weather is warm enough that I only had a motorcycle for 3 years and only had to take the bus to work maybe three times due to weather. It can get cold and snow but it never lasts long. The airports connect or fly direct to everywhere. The food scene is great plus you can get blue crabs, lots of arts and shows and new York Is only a few hours away,, and one of the best ball parks in Camden Yards. I left because I needed a change, didn’t like the taxes/govt nor my chances of getting a good enough job to afford living in the city. It really is a different feel from anywhere else on the east coast. I’d move back eventually maybe, for the right job, but I’m not done with the rest of the world yet.
I lived in Eastern/central Michigan in college (Kettering, Flint) and you couldn’t pay me enough to move to any where in central or eastern Michigan. Grey long bullE36 M3 winters, lots of economically depressed areas and high crime (at least they were 10 years ago), godawful roads, and I found a lot of people there a lot like Curtis’s pittsburghers except ex UAW instead of steel workers. Traverse city was gorgeous however it’s a long way from anything.
My wife lived in Chicago for 7 years before we met and while we visit and think it’s a great city neither of us want to live in that big of a city again we don’t think.
My wife and I actually met on the ferry to Alaska and have lived in Fairbanks for almost 6 years now. We love it here but want to be closer to family in the lower 48, feel that we have both more or less topped ourselves out job-wise since the town is so small, and want our 2yo daughter and soon to be born son to live in a place with a bit more access to the rest of the world. It was also -35F today, that gets old but doesn’t last as long as it used to according to the old sourdoughs. You do kinda get used to it but I’d really like to wear my motorcycle jacket more and my down parka less. Still, the northern lights are out tonight...
We wanted to try Seattle but we didn’t hit the megamillions, powerball, or the Amazon/Microsoft lottery so we can’t afford to live close enough for us to the city. Love everything else about the city though.
Portland seems... nice. Funky, but not necessarily in a good way, yet bland and definitely had a “second place is ok!” feel to it.
Our short list is topped by Albuquerque/Santa Fe, partly because of the qualities mentioned elsewhere in this thread, partly because my wife is from New Mexico and has family there, and partly for the chile (red or green, there’s no wrong answer). I feel that ABQ may be on the upswing economically and it’s still affordable to live there. Tucson also has its appeal but dang it’s hot there in summer...
San Antonio is about the only place in Texas we’d consider. We got engaged there and need to go back for a longer stay to feel the city out more but we’ve both been several times and liked it.
Honestly after reading this thread we’re probably going to investigate Huntsville a bit too.