Hydrogen as a fuel? Inside the technology Toyota is developing

J.A.
By J.A. Ackley
May 4, 2023 | Toyota, ice, Hydrogen, Internal Combustion Engine | Posted in News and Notes | Never miss an article

Photography Courtesy Toyota unless otherwise credited

There is a carbon-neutral path for us as car lovers!” boldly claimed Toyota president Akio Toyoda at the 2023 Tokyo Auto Salon. “We don’t want to leave any car lovers behind!”

Photography Credit: Noriaki Mitsuhashi/N-RAK PHOTO AGENCY/Toyota

Toyota wants the internal combustion engine to continue. To make that happen they are working with carbon-neutral fuels, including hydrogen. To help develop that, they are using motorsports.

Motorsports as a Testing Ground

None

Toyota started running a hydrogen-fueled ICE GR Corolla in the Super Taikyu endurance series in 2021. The car employs a version of the 1618cc straight-three G16E-GTS engine that you’d find in the GR Corolla.

According to a Google translation of Toyota Gazoo Racing’s Japanese website, the goal for running in the series is simple:

“Run, break, fix, and become stronger … Train cars in a harsh motorsports environment.”

Koji Sato, who’s set to succeed Toyoda as Toyota’s president in April, confirmed the premise behind running its Corolla in the series. “By pushing the car to its limits, problems can be quickly identified,” Sato told the company’s Toyota Times. “We can then agilely formulate countermeasures to be ready for the next race. If you are developing technology for a simpler car, much can be done in the laboratory; however, through the Super Taikyu Series, we are conducting a major demonstration trial aimed at achieving a hydrogen society.”

Toyota Times revealed what gains they made in 2022: “This season, the hydrogen-powered Corolla increased its power output by 7%, torque by 5%, and driving range by 15%. Compared to its debut race last year [in 2021], output has improved by 24%, and the driving range has improved by 30%. Pre-ignition suppression technology has also steadily improved, with the frequency of pre-ignition during the final race being reduced to less than half of what it was during the opening race.”

The Challenges of Hydrogen

None

Hydrogen is incredibly abundant, and burning it results in water as the byproduct. The trick, however, is separating it from the other elements that it readily bonds with.

Toyota produces the hydrogen it uses from two plants powered by solar cells. “Up to 370 Nm3 of hydrogen is produced per hour by electrolyzing water with electricity derived from solar power,” said Toyota of its hydrogen fuel factory in the Yamanashi Prefecture.

Now that you have the hydrogen, you have to get it to the vehicle. To transport it to the races, Toyota uses bio-fuel trailers hauled by electric fuel cell trucks. Since starting the program, they’ve increased the capacity of the hydrogen tanks by approximately four-fold. Toyota achieved this by using lightweight resin liners in the tanks that upped the pressure from 20 MPa to 45 MPa. Prior to the 2022 season, they looked to increase tank pressure even further to 70 MPa.

To improve the energy density of hydrogen, Toyota would like to go from using gaseous hydrogen to liquid hydrogen. This will not only extend the range of the fuel, but also the applications for it.

Currently, the Corolla uses four fuel tanks that add up to 180 liters of capacity (47.6 gallons). During pit stops, they refill them from both sides of the car. To quickly fuel the car is a challenge as “normally, the temperature inside the tank increases rapidly if filled all at once, but we have changed the filling port and piping to handle large flow rates while ensuring safety to make sure the upper temperature limit isn’t reached,” according to Toyota. They have reduced the time to refill the tanks to one and a half minutes.

One Common Concern

None

When many people think of hydrogen, an image comes to their mind: the Hindenburg airship engulfed in flames. Yes, hydrogen is also highly combustible, but that applies to many fuels.

Last August, Toyota ran into that perception when it did a demonstration run with a hydrogen-fueled GR Yaris during the World Rally Championship event in Ypres, Belgium. It was Toyota’s first venture with a hydrogen-fueled ICE car outside of Japan.

“In the past, hydrogen was commonly associated with dangerous explosions,” Toyoda told the company’s Toyota Times. “When I recently visited Belgium to drive a WRC demo car, we had to do a great deal of explaining about infrastructure safety measures.

“But when they found out that the president himself would be driving, the organizers’ tone changed to ‘go ahead and try it.’

“Whether it’s hydrogen or any other new option, there are always risks and dangers at first. And when it comes to the hydrogen engine’s development, I assure you that Toyota’s accounting department has been scrutinizing the feasibility even more than you guys!

“However, my actions can change the way others act. In particular, I believe that my risk-taking is one of the reasons why more and more people are joining the cause.”

Back to the Future

None

For those who love old cars, what about them? What happens if fossil fuels become difficult to obtain? Toyota’s working on carbon-neutral solutions, which included the AE86 H2 Concept dubbed “Trueno.“
It has an engine converted to run on hydrogen. It is the same internal combustion engine, the 4A-GEU, that came with the car.

A Google translation of the Japanese Toyota Gazoo Racing site provides additional details: “… we have developed a vehicle that can drive while enjoying the appeal of internal combustion engines such as sound and vibration. Two Mirai high-pressure hydrogen tanks are installed at the rear, and other changes include injectors, fuel delivery, and plugs to minimize the scale of modifications.”

“There are lots of people here at Auto Salon who wants to enjoy their car life with their favorite cars,” Toyoda said. “Although the AE86 conversion technology is still under development ... By talking about this today with car lovers ... I hope to dismiss the fear that we won’t be able to drive our beloved cars when we go carbon neutral. On the contrary, there is a carbon neutral path that car lovers can take.”

Going Forward

None

Photography Credit: Toyota Times

How close are we to seeing hydrogen-fueled ICE cars in the showroom and conversion kits for your AE 86?

“Commercialization is still a way off,” Toyoda told Toyota Times. “In terms of climbing the mountain toward market-ready hydrogen engines, we are still less than halfway to the summit.”

Yes, Toyota has created a visual using Mount Fuji, with 10 “stations,” as it makes progress to bringing hydrogen-fueled cars to the market. During June’s 24-hour race at Fuji Speedway, Toyota said it was at its fourth station. As of February 7, it has updated that status.

“Since then, development has continued, and there is no doubt that we are now going from the fourth to the fifth station,’ said Tomoya Takahashi, GR Vehicle Development Division’s General Manager, in the Toyota Times. “Aiming for mass production, emission development at the fourth station has started in parallel with development for the race. A new dedicated team has been established to accelerate development.

“The fifth station’s functionality and reliability measures are issues we found to be caused by the high-rpm, high-load environment used at Super Taikyu races. These issues are also being worked on via mass production development by the new team in parallel with the race.

“At the sixth station, we have tank downsizing. This is an effort to increase the driving range with liquid hydrogen.

“I think liquid hydrogen will be an even more difficult road to travel, so I would like to start by releasing a car that uses gaseous hydrogen.

“We have started moving toward the fourth, fifth, and sixth stations in our climb up the mountain. Although it is now possible to safely run the engine in the next step after working on the first station’s problems, such as abnormal combustion, we have yet to reach the stage where we have fully mastered the underlying mechanics.

“We would like to improve the road conditions so that our partners in the hydrogen-use area can climb the mountain with peace of mind.”

The road may be long, but Akio Toyoda, who continue on as chairman of Toyota after stepping down as president, still remains committed to the hydrogen dream.

“While pursuing hydrogen-powered engines may not seem rational right now, the truth is that we also have considerable support from fellow car-lovers,” Toyoda said. “As long as there are such like-minded car-lovers in the world, I feel that I still have a role to play, so I’d like to continue our endeavor for the time being.”

Join Free Join our community to easily find more Toyota, ice, Hydrogen and Internal Combustion Engine articles.
Comments
Chris_V
Chris_V UberDork
2/10/23 9:14 a.m.

I used to be a proponent of the hydrogen future, but for 30 years it's always BEEN a future 5-10 years away, due to the massive problems with it. It takes more energy to generate, it requires custom tanks that can handle the 10,000 psi that it must be stored at to get any sort of energy density out of it, as the smallest atom it can slip through other materials and is HIGHLY flammable making leaks a Really Big Deal. Hydrogen embrittlement is still a thing. And the fact that there's NO infrastructure for it, while there is electricity pretty much everywhere now, makes it a real hard sell (and you can't refuel at home like you can with electricity).

While the idea of quickly refilling with hydrogen is appealing as a positive, there are also problems that so far are not yet solved - for example, with economically generating hydrogen, and with doing so in an energy efficient way. The most appealing way from a clean energy perspective is to use electrolysis of water using wind and solar power. But this process isn't cheap, so the resulting hydrogen is a good deal more expensive than gas (while charging a BEV is a good deal cheaper than gas); and, you lose energy when you convert from electrical energy to chemical in electrolysis - it's a lot more direct/efficient to just use that electrical energy to charge BEVs. And then there will be a need for building out a very extensive network of hydrogen filling stations - which won't be trivial. These are not small problems.

No, this is a hedge against Japanese government regulations. That's all. Hydrogen is a non-starter globally for passenger cars. It might be good for trains and long haul trucks, if the hydrogen can be generated cheap enough

GameboyRMH
GameboyRMH GRM+ Memberand MegaDork
2/10/23 9:30 a.m.

I think Toyota's making a wrong turn again. In terms of hydrogen infrastructure, it basically doesn't exist right now and it's a nightmare fuel to transport and store, while we already have liquid hydrocarbons at every gas station and electricity in most every structure. Hydrogen can only practically be made a liquid at cryogenic temperatures. A hydrogen-powered ICE is also still turning about 2 units of energy into waste heat for every 1 that makes it to the wheels. A fuel-cell hydrogen car doesn't have that issue, but it does have a high up-front cost and high weight like an EV.

Also right now, fueling a car with hydrogen costs about as much as fueling it with gas, and almost all of the hydrogen available is produced as a fossil fuel byproduct.

alfadriver
alfadriver MegaDork
2/10/23 9:44 a.m.

Kind of surprised they pivoted to ICEs instead of fuel cells- about a year ago Physics Girl did a long drive of a Toyota Fuel Cell car and talked alot about it on her YT channel.  

H2 ICE's need help to make equal power of gas- since H2 isn't as energy rich for it's proper combustion as gasoline is.

I'm also not going to say they are making a mistake in direction, as I know they are very active in EVs.  This seems to be hedging their bets where H2 may be a better option.

edit- also, the work to develop it isn't very expensive, it's not as if you have to develop an totally new engine, and most of the storage issues have been worked through.  The thing still hanging out there is emissions, as dealing with NOx is still a requirement.  I know I would have a blast working on that, as in recent years, I've learned some cool details on how to deal with it with no CO around.

J.A. Ackley
J.A. Ackley Senior Editor
2/10/23 10:20 a.m.

In reply to alfadriver :

I have driven the Toyota Mirai, which uses a hydrogen fuel cell. To me it felt like driving an EV sedan that focused on comfort and a smooth ride rather than sheer sportiness like some trend toward. It also made bubbly sounds when you got on the gas ... err accelerator ... pedal.

I'd like to drive a H2 car. I'm curious what it would feel like - and sound like. From the videos I've seen, the cars sound like regular ICE cars.

VolvoHeretic
VolvoHeretic GRM+ Memberand HalfDork
2/10/23 10:30 a.m.

Hey, I'm ready to go, I've already got the fuel tank. smiley 2 miles away from me there already is a hydrogen fueling station which was the first in the nation experiment to run 3 pickups on hydrogen produced from 2 wind tower generators. They expanded it to run 2 diesel tractors also but for some reason, there is no follow up on the conclusions of the study.

Wind-to-hydrogen plant first in nation

j_tso
j_tso Dork
2/10/23 10:34 a.m.
alfadriver said:

Kind of surprised they pivoted to ICEs instead of fuel cells- about a year ago Physics Girl did a long drive of a Toyota Fuel Cell car and talked alot about it on her YT channel. 

I don't think they're pivoting but providing an option. You can have your fuel cell car for commuting and a combustion car for the track day when you want revs and noise. I'm sure development was pushed because now former CEO Akio Toyoda is a petrol head.

Keichi Tsuchiya got to drive the Corolla

 

sleepyhead the buffalo
sleepyhead the buffalo GRM+ Memberand PowerDork
2/10/23 10:42 a.m.

Here's the actual press conference from the 2023 Tokyo Auto Salon, which includes english subtitles:

 

which I linked to in a thread about the BEV and H2 AE86's.  Watching that video about the two "mules", and the relative lack of power currently of the H2 combustion 4A-GE, I kinda wonder why they're not utilizing H2 combustion in one of their hybrid synergy systems?  Seems to me like that would be another place where their edge in integrating EV's would well supplement the lack of power and torque on the H2 combustion.

Driven5
Driven5 UberDork
2/10/23 10:46 a.m.

I think we'd be get farther faster by putting more energy into biofuel development.

alfadriver
alfadriver MegaDork
2/10/23 10:56 a.m.

In reply to Driven5 :

That's actually out side of the automotive industry, and more a combination of the ag industry plus some oil.  That's been a massive part of the work for a really long time- IIRC, the first time switchgrass based fuel was brought up was in the 70s.  

Especially the work to try to get butanol- which is closer to gasoline than ethanol is.  But it requires some special tools.

Basically, everyone is working on everything, trying to find that magical breakthrough to make their path a better one than all of the others.

Keith Tanner
Keith Tanner GRM+ Memberand MegaDork
2/10/23 11:31 a.m.

One thing that doesn't get mentioned much about hydrogen is refueling speed. Everyone expects it to be like gasoline, you just hook up a hose and 2 minutes later you're on your way. But if I understand correctly, that means a high pressure supply tank since the car stores the fuel at 350-700 bar. Normal industrial storage of H2 is something like 200 bar. So you need a high pressure transfer tank, which means a whole lot of pumping action to refill that's slower than filling the car. It's like trying to use a high-consumption air tool on your compressor. So after a few cars have suckled at the transfer tank, there's a delay while it refills. This article refers to a 15 minute "refresh" time. So while it might only take 5-7 minutes to refuel, you may end up having to wait more like 20-22 if your timing is wrong.

I think the only real advantage H2 has over a battery EV is the ability to store more energy, which benefits the heavy users like commercial vehicles the most. And those commercial vehicles are more likely to be operating out of hubs with coordination, so they can work around the lack of infrastructure and the "refresh" time constraints. That makes me think that big over the road trucks are going to be the first real use, switching to electric trucks for last mile delivery. Think of the big triple trailer FedEx road trains and the local delivery vans, for example.

Private passenger vehicles see wildly random use, they need far more infrastructure. That's the biggest complaint/concern about EVs for a lot of people, and this is in a country that has a very well established electrical grid.

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners
hJasqKnBh4SjLHkqiIhUzfFQChwNzno6V4EQ64PqB4WOGajN4Nt63z7p2NLxYkTY