Expert advice on aftermarket wheels | separating truth from hype

Scott
By Scott Lear
Dec 30, 2023 | wheels, Tires & Wheels | Posted in Tires & Wheels | From the Aug. 2015 issue | Never miss an article

Photography Credit: J.G. Pasterjak

[GRM+ members read this article first. Subscribe and gain access to more exclusive content for only $3/month.]

All cars have the wheel in common, though the wheels on our cars couldn’t be more diverse in form and construction. There’s an emotional element as well, as personalizing a vehicle often starts with changing the wheels, whether for aesthetic or performance reasons.

In motorsports, there are genuine, measurable gains to be had from swapping out the stock wheels for something lighter, stronger, larger or smaller. Aftermarket wheels can also open the door to other upgrades, like larger brake systems and wider tire footprints.

With hundreds if not thousands of options in any particular size, however, there can be a paralyzing number of choices. Budget plays a factor, of course, and certain wheel types have a reputation for being race-appropriate, but how can you really know what you’re getting? We asked a number of wheel industry experts three basic questions to learn a bit more about what makes the wheels on the race car go round and round.

“OEM wheels are actually some of the strongest you will ever have on your car. The wheel is so critical to safety that OEMs engineer theirs to be extremely strong, corrosion-resistant, and fitment-conservative to allow for extra room within the wheel well. 

An aftermarket performance wheel will typically be lighter due to a higher level of manufacturing, like forging or flow forming. It will push the limits of weight in exchange for extreme durability. What a lot of people don’t know is that OEM strength and durability standards are generally triple those of the aftermarket. So make sure when choosing a performance wheel that your supplier has the testing information to back up the low weight.” 

Eddie Lee
Mackin Industries/Volk Racing

“Of course racers are going to be looking for the lightest, strongest wheel for their money, but quality is extremely important. There are a lot of companies now buying wheels from factories that don’t have the highest quality control or the correct build specifications for a given application. Choosing a lightweight wheel is great, but maybe it’s not correctly load-rated for your vehicle.

Maybe the reason the wheel is so light is because they removed necessary material in areas that will now be susceptible to cracking and stress fractures. 

Choosing a wheel that’s built by a company with years of experience, high quality control and an understanding of what applications it will be used for is key and ensures that the wheel is reliable and safe while remaining as light and strong as it can be.” 

Scott Weiss
König

"The single most important factor when choosing a wheel is what the customer is going to be doing with the car. Someone who is looking for performance on the street using street tires doesn’t have to worry as much about strength and stiffness as someone who is going to the track every weekend with R-compound tires. And slicks are another significant step up over R-compound DOT tires.”

David Schardt
Forgeline

“Right now, hands down, flow-forming technology is one of the construction methods that offers the best overall benefits, and it’s something that König is extremely proud of. Flow-forming technology is a manufacturing process that shares similar properties to those found in the forging process.The end result is a product that is lighter, stronger and has greater elongation and shock resistance compared to a cast wheel. More importantly, we can offer these amazing product benefits to the customer at a price level that is still incredibly affordable.”

Scott Weiss
König

“A true fully forged one-piece monoblock wheel offers the greatest performance gains, as the 6061 material–heat-treated to T6 specifications–offers the greatest strength-to-mass ratio. The metal is stronger and deflects less under force, which is a performance gain in itself. Reduced deflection gives the wheel more fatigue strength as well. This allows you to machine the spokes thinner or simply use less material as opposed to a cast or flow-formed wheel.

"Forged three-piece wheels can have great fatigue and stiffness characteristics as well, but if you’re comparing the same design between a one- and a three-piece wheel, the one-piece forged wheel will be stiffer and typically lighter due to not having the bolts to hold it together.”

David Schardt
Forgeline

"There are so many new manufacturing techniques, like carbon wheels and flow forming–but the best and most advanced is mold forging. This is a technique used by Rays (Volk Racing) and BBS, the only companies capable of manufacturing with this technique in-house. It allows a wheel to exhibit extreme lightness and durability. Unlike traditional machine-forged wheels, the grain structure of the high-end aluminum is organized throughout a mold-forged wheel.

"Carbon wheels are super light, but durability comes into question: Once there is an impact beyond the carbon strength threshold, the structure will crack and break. A mold-forged wheel will still retain air in the tire, so the wheel performs better than all other wheels while retaining a safety element as well.”

Eddie Lee
Mackin Industries/Volk Racing

"Trust that the wheel brand has the integrity and desire to ensure that their product quality and service are held to the highest standards. Trust that the brand has the expertise and experience to design and manufacture your wheels to the highest quality and with the appropriate specifications needed for your specific application–racing, street performance or luxury. You can easily spend a lot of money on wheels that are not only inferior to your OEM wheels, but may be completely unsafe, either due to a lack of technical knowledge, poor quality of manufacture, or use in incorrect applications.” 

Alan Peltier
HRE Performance Wheels

“Design and weight are equally important. Several TSW wheels are manufactured using a production technique called rotary forging, where the rim of the wheel is forged at high pressure while the wheel is spun at high speed. This alters the molecular structure and enhances the strength of the alloy. The weight savings is on the outer rim of the wheel, which dramatically reduces rotational mass and enhances vehicle performance.” 

Linda Schmidt
TSW Alloy Wheels

“A true race wheel has several advantages, weight usually being the top dog. [Reducing] rotational unsprung wheel mass is one of the best ways to gain cheap horsepower, increase handling and improve braking all in one package.”

Wade Huisman
Keizer Wheels

Join Free Join our community to easily find more wheels and Tires & Wheels articles.
Comments
Trackmouse
Trackmouse UltraDork
1/30/18 12:51 p.m.

Ok. Now tell us about the cheap wheels we can afford. cheeky

te72
te72 New Reader
1/31/18 12:29 a.m.

Have had a set of XXR 527 on the Supra for a couple years now. Haven't hit anything, so I can't comment on strength in that regard. Last I checked, you're not supposed to hit things anyway?

 

As far as satisfaction goes, they're reasonably light for the size, and were reasonably priced as well. Doesn't hurt that they look good and came with blank centercaps so I can put hello kitty stickers on them.

Trackmouse
Trackmouse UltraDork
1/31/18 1:03 a.m.

In reply to te72 :

So, how have they faired for auto sport use? This is where the rumors, horror stories, and the “buy name brand” stories foment. 

STM317
STM317 Dork
1/31/18 5:05 a.m.

Owning a set of Forgelines is on my bucket list. But spending more on a set of wheels than I did on the vehicle is a tough pill to swallow.

MazdaFace
MazdaFace HalfDork
1/31/18 6:01 a.m.

When I worked at Firestone we had a customer with knock off China te37 on a 370z. Came in complaining of a tire balance issue and we noticed half the spokes were cracked all the way through on his back wheels. He got lucky. Absolute disaster waiting to happen. Totally turned me off even the thought of off brand eBay wheels. 

Rodan
Rodan Reader
1/31/18 6:28 a.m.
STM317 said:

Owning a set of Forgelines is on my bucket list. But spending more on a set of wheels than I did on the vehicle is a tough pill to swallow.

With what I paid for my track Miata, almost everything cost more than the car did! cheeky

nderwater
nderwater UltimaDork
1/31/18 7:37 a.m.

There are a lot of wheel brands out there -- is anyone keeping a list of reputable makers of affordable flow formed / rotary forged wheels?

freetors
freetors Reader
1/31/18 7:45 a.m.

We have Rota RB25's on our MGB. I have been totally satisfied. Thirteen pounds for 15x6. Totally straight out of the box. I have accidently hit bumps and potholes that physically hurt and thought for sure that it would have damaged the wheels. But they just take the hit and keep on going. 

I think it's important to realize that if you're tracking your car or putting heavy loads on it, any wheel is eventually going to break or crack. And jut the right hit will do the same for any wheel too. The lighter your wheels the more risky this becomes.

z31maniac
z31maniac MegaDork
1/31/18 7:53 a.m.
nderwater said:

There are a lot of wheel brands out there -- is anyone keeping a list of reputable makers of affordable flow formed / rotary forged wheels?

Basically everything "affordable" that isn't super heavy is flow formed now. And there are plenty. 

REAL forged wheels are horrifically expensive. Typically $700+ per wheel.

ProDarwin
ProDarwin PowerDork
1/31/18 7:57 a.m.
Trackmouse said:

Ok. Now tell us about the cheap wheels we can afford. cheeky

For what fitment?

Seems to me if you drive anything that is autocross/tracked frequently, there are a ton of cheap options out there.  I usually start with TRM wheels because that is pretty much the target:  cheap, light, motorsports oriented.

Now if only their 15x8 Miata wheels had a higher offset...

You'll need to log in to post.

Our Preferred Partners
M4Wkgsr77Cqanu1r0w1Zk49OyaMfjO6PtYiaTnmIl9bSsRsjfCk4EASWdc8C27kU