Stumbled across an article on one of Amtrak's stranger and more short-lived passenger trains, the Hilltopper, yesterday. I'd never heard of that one, and, boy, was it a weird one. It lived just two years, had the lowest average speed of the Amtrak fleet in 1979, the lowest average ridership, and spent 30 miles of it's trip running backwards in either direction.
First, there's some strange backstory, involving another short-lived Amtrak train, the Mountaineer. When Amtrak took over passenger service in 1971, two of the trains they inherited were New York Central's Chicago-Cincinatti James Whitcomb Riley and the Chesapeake & Ohio's Cincinatti-Washington DC/Newport News George Washington. Amtrak merged the two of them into a single Chicago-DC train that used the James Whitcomb Riley name for the westbound run and the George Washington name for the eastbound run.
After Amtrak's formation, West Virginia senator Robert Byrd began pitching a fit over the fact that there had been no passenger trains serving his rural constituents in West Virginia since the N&W's Pocahontas had been discontinued in 1971 and began pushing for Amtrak service over the N&W mainline from Cincinatti to Norfolk. Byrd pressured the Department of Transportation to add a route over this line, and in March of 1975, Amtrak guaranteed two years of operation of this new train, known as the Mountaineer, while warning that the train would "habitually lose money." Amtrak president Paul Reistrup projected costs of $4.5 million a year while only taking in $900,000 in the first year. To make the run viable the Mountaineer would need to carry 150–300 people daily between Norfolk and Cincinnati. The Mountaineer would depart from Chicago as a section of the George Washington, then split off at the C&O yard in Ashland, KY and swing south across the lower area of West Virginia and Virginia to Norfolk. The consist was a baggage-dormitory, two coaches, a grille diner and a 10-roomette 6-bedroom sleeper car, and when available, one of the coaches was a dome car. In January of 1977, the train was reconfigured to use just three Amfleet cars, two coaches and one cafe car, losing the dome car and sleeper car. Ridership on the Mountaineer over its two-year probationary period was disappointing: 58,991 in 1975 and 53,400 in 1976. Monetary losses were far higher than expected: $5.7 million in 1975 and $14.9 million in 1976, and as a result Amtrak discontinued the Mountaineer on May 31, 1977 after the 2 year probationary period ended.
Amtrak's termination of the Mountaineer caused another temper tantrum from senator Byrd, as well as West Virginia senator Harley Staggers, that their constituents weren't being served again, and in 1977, Amtrak rolled out what was dubbed as "to as "the poster child of pork-barrel passenger trains" and "an example of everything that was wrong with Amtrak". This was the Hilltopper. It would operate south out of Washington DC on the Richmond, Fredericksburg & Potomac/Seaboard Coast Line to Petersburg, VA, and then hop on the Norfolk & Western to head west to the bustling metropolis of Catlettsburg, Kentucky, where it would offer a connection to the James Whitcomb Riley/George Washington. Again, this still had the issue of serving a lot of rural areas with minimal ridership, and now it no longer served Suffolk or Norfolk except by a bus connection.
It also had another issue. The N&W/SCL diamond at Petersburg lacked a connection at the northwest corner or southeast corner. There were only connections at the southwest and northeast corners, so the train would have to run past the diamond into SCL's Collier Yard and then reverse up the connector at the southwest corner and onto the N&W, which would have the train running backwards for the east-west leg. Amtrak's solution was a jury-rigged affair; 30 miles north of Petersburg the train would be turned at RF&P's Acca Wye in Richmond, Virgina and run 30 miles south backwards to Collier Yard and then it would be aimed the right direction when it got on the N&W. Except that Amtrak lacked cab cars, and reverse-running on the main was prohibited unless the cab signal pickups were set up for bidirectional running, and the ones on the GE P30CHs were not. So, the RF&P had GP7 #102 on standby, which would hook onto the back of the Hilltopper and tow the train in reverse from Acca Wye to Collier Yard. And, this had to be done in reverse on the eastbound run as well.
Like the Mountaineer, the Hilltopper was an immediate loser. In 1978, Amtrak tried merging it into the DC-Boston Night Owl, in hopes of bolstering ridership. The train averaged 33 passengers per trip in 1978, dropping to between 2 and 15 per trip in 1979, and many of the train's riders were former N&W employees with lifetime passes. . Its trip of 1,674 miles took an average journey time of 26 hours 35 minutes resulting in an average speed of 37.1 miles per hour, the lowest on the long-distance system. Farebox recovery was a dismal 25%, with the train losing $200,000 per year. The Hilltopper was one of five routes cut on October 1, 1979, as part of a reorganization by the Carter Administration , and the only of the five where no federal injunctions were obtained to keep service running.
Realistically, a Budd RDC set likely would have been a better use than a GE P30CH and a GP7 towing around a single Amfleet coach and an Amfleet dinette, but Byrd had insisted that his constituents get new Amfleet equipment. Also, Amtrak didn't have a lot of RDCs, most railroads held them onto for commuter service and then they were conveyed to whatever commuter agency took over for those. Also, by 1977, the newest RDCs were 15 years old, and the oldest were pushing 30 years old, and the big RDC owners were B&M, NYC and New Haven, so a lot of them had lived rough lives. Removing food service also would have stemmed the financial bleeding, but pork barrel spending and logic don't go hand-in-hand, and I'm sure Byrd and Staggers were insisting that it also offered food service.
The end of the Hilltopper spelled the end of intercity rail service along much of its route in southwest Virginia and West Virginia, although there are still occasional pushes for restoration of service to the route.