A few final thoughts on the Civic Si that I didn't buy:
I may actually prefer the shape of the Civic. I certainly like the sedan profile and rear three quarter view better. I didn't really care about the Integra being a five door, but I know that there's history there. I'm fine living with a trunk and its stiffer chassis. These sloping hatches look sort of bulbous and goofy to my eye. I want my hatchbacks to look like hatchbacks, but only Volkswagen seems to do that these days, at least in this country.
The grills look very different on these cars, but I like the both. The Civic grill is especially cool. The lights on the Integra are super nice though.
I've never liked black wheels, but somehow these dark metallic gray wheels look great to me on the red Acura. I think if I bought the Civic, I would have bought different wheels for the street. It's kind of a moot point tough, because I'd end up with a second set of wheels and tires for either car anyway, and I would have just used the stock Honda wheels for track day tires anyway. In fact, I'd be fine with the black Honda wheels with sticky tires for the Acura on the track.
I've heard that the non adjustable shocks on the Civic can be a little harsh on the street. I like the adjustable dampers that come with the Tech package on the Integra.
I was factoring in the cost of immediately buying new wheels and shocks for the Civic when I was making my decision.
I didn't care that the Honda doesn't have power seats, in fact I prefer that. But I would have wanted more adjustability, and I absolutely wanted heated seats, which Honda doesn't offer in the US, but does in Canada. It's also weird that Honda doesn't seem to make any effort to make the front seats match the rear. Maybe they were going for the tuner look.
The Acura has very comfortable, multi adjustable, heated power seats. Admittedly, there is some difference in looks and material between the front and rear seats of the Acura, but it's not as dramatic.
I didn't want a red Honda, I thought it was too bright. But I think the darker metallic red looks fantastic on the Acura. I really thought I wanted a white car again, but I prefer an old school gloss white. Both of these cars come in pearl white. Yuck. And the dark wheels didn't look good with either car in white.
The Honda's rear spoiler is really nice. The Acura's rear spoiler just kind of silly. I do like the optional carbon fiber spoiler for the Acura and considered adding one, but I was disappointed to learn that you have to drill new holes through the paint of the hatch to install it. That really surprised me for a genuine accessory part. I'll stick with what I have. I'm not going to drill into brand new factory paint.
The Honda dealership that I was working with was really great about trying to help me, even though it didn't work out. I'm glad that we at least bought the Accord from them.
^Sullivan Honda.
All of the other Honda dealerships that I talked to were really being d*cks when it came dealing with these particular cars. The Civic Si is a special car, but it's not that special.
Neither is the Integra for that matter, but at least the Acura dealers weren't trying to act like it was. They just wanted to help me buy a new car.
^Acura of Bedford Hills.
The Civic Si is truly a bargain if you can get one at MSRP, but the Integra was the better choice for me.