So I went and looked at the Neon.
It's a '98 EX Coupe, no AC, no power anything, very, very clean, new summer tires, new winter tires on rims, virtually no rust, no dings etc. And its a DOHC!
Here's the issue though, and it's a bit weird so please read:
-Facts - it HAD a remote start at one point, and has an aftermarket stereo and a rats nest of wires under the drivers side dash (I think this is relevant, please read on)
It was running when I got there, but sounded really nice, quiet, revved nice etc. I let it run for a bit, the cooling fan came on, all the lights work, seems really solid.
I asked to take it for a short drive to the end of the street (no plates on it), he said sure. I hit the clutch and it made a god-awful screech (IT SOUNDED EXACTLY LIKE THE STARTER WAS ENGAGING). This only happened at the very bottom of the clutch pedal travel...
When I released the clutch, the noise continued for a couple seconds then stopped. Hit the clutch again, the noise started again. Finally, I hit the clutch, the noise started but wouldn't stop. I shut off the engine, and it wouldn't start again. Lots of battery, just no starter. The starter was very hot and smelled. Oh yeah, it's a new starter...
Here's my theory: Something in the clutch safety switch/wiring rats nest/former remote starter is triggering the starter circuit and killing the starter. Of course, I led the seller to believe that I think it's a serious issue with a bearing etc in the trans and the starter issue is unrelated.
I'm thinking of offering him $600 or so. Is my theory realistic? Is there something in the trans/clutch that would make that sound or are my instincts correct? The clutch cable feels nice and smooth, clutch travel feels perfectly normal, no noises from the trans running in neutral etc.
What's the deal?