Ok, I kinda crapped on Subarus in my previous response. I have the right to do so. I've owned two (a 2002 WRX wagon and a 2009 WRX hatch) and as much as I'd like to put on the rose-tinted lenses, I can't because of the experiences I had with them and SOA.
The 2002 was a fun car, and very easy to tune and make fast, but it had it's share of issues. Some examples include the fuel lines spewing raw fuel all over the engine in cold weather under 15 degrees, the driver's seat tracks snapping, rear differential whining, differential and subframe clunking, etc. I had to go through and repair all of that on my own, and while some of it were as simple as upgrading bushings (on the clunking issues), some of the other issues (like the seat and fuel leak) were ignored by SOA. The fuel one was later addressed by a recall, but not after many people had to shell out $600+ at the dealer to have them repaired out of warranty, and only certain "cold weather" states were covered. Strangely, Massachusetts was not one of them. Just for reference, it's 7 degrees out right now. I can guarantee that someone's early 2002-03 WRX is puking fuel all over their engine block at this very minute.
And I was lucky with mine, because mine never spun bearings like a lot of the other ones! Granted, my car was tuned and had an aftermarket turbo-back exhaust, but that should not have an effect on puking fuel lines or snapping seat tracks.
The 2009 was a different story. I wanted to keep it mostly stock, and I bought the extra Subaru Gold Plus warranty that the dealer told me "covered just about everything bumper to bumper, including all the driveline parts". My thinking is that since I modded the 2002 so much, I'd keep the mods to the 2009 very basic, and I wasn't touching the tune or adding power adders. I did only a few basic mods to the car: a STI rear sway bar (a whole 2mm bigger, got it on partial trade for the stock summer tires) wider wheels when my stock ones were destroyed by a tire shop (17x8's, which they later offered on the newer models anyway), and a Kartboy shifter and bushings. Also, I replaced the awful stereo and speakers with aftermarket ones. That's it.
At around 50k, the A/C compressor quit. I guess that happens a lot on these, fair enough, covered under warranty. Then, the power outlets started popping fuses intermittently. Dealer said it's because I had a cell phone charger plugged in, and that's not what they are meant for. Huh? They replaced the fuses, and I had to make sure my phone was charged before leaving the house. Then, the glove box door fell off. And then the air vents fell out. They covered the door, but not the vents. Another head scratcher. Glad to see that I'm not the only one who has had this problem.
Here's where I drew the line. I started having issues with the transmission, pedals, and clutch around 55k or so. The clutch pedal felt like it was broken, and had detents in it as you depressed it, and it creaked and cracked. I watched the whole pedal assembly flex as I pushed it down by hand! Subaru said there was nothing wrong. The NASIOC solution is to TIG weld in an aluminum pedal assembly brace, because SOA refuses to acknowledge the problem. Then, I started to hear the throwout bearing make noise every time the clutch was depressed, along with the clutch fork squeaking. The dealer said that if I wanted to have it looked at, I had to pay for shop time up front, to the tune of $1100+, and if they find a problem, then they will cover it. If not, then I'm out the $1100+. SOA was no help, either. I pretty much got the cold shoulder when I said something to a SOA representative. They said it was up to dealer discretion. At that point, I lost faith in Subaru and traded it in. And again, I got it easy. My car was built about two weeks after the bad batch of cranks with unfinished journals made their way into short block assemblies.
And as far as the Brotato comment: I live in MA. There are lots of VW people up here with stanced cars, but the Subaru stanced ones outnumber them 3:1 at the very least, as shocking as that may be. The average WRX driver here is in their late teens-early 20's, and 9/10 times it's a flat brimmer. Older drivers have all moved onto greener pastures and other car marques. Take a look at NASIOC's Off Topic section. It's mostly older former Subaru drivers that have moved on to other cars, like Ford Focus ST's, MS3's, GTI's, Infinitis, BMW's, etc.
I think I've seen maybe one MS3 with stupid wheels and stretched tires on it in all the years they have been out. And the Brotato crowd keeps crashing WRX's left and right. I've never owned a car where the insurance premiums go UP every year until I had the 2009.
And Hondas... well... you got me there.
I just want to see someone else try and make a car like the WRX and make it dependable, look good, have a decent interior, and offer a wagon/hatch variant. Not only has Subaru forgotten how to do this, as evidenced by the new Corolla WRX, Subaru lost me as a new car customer with the way they handled the two cars I owned. They would not stand behind their products when it came time to step up to bat, even when I paid EXTRA for the privilege.
And for the record, with all that said, I would (stupidly) jump at the chance to own a nice, clean 2004-05 WRB STI with gold wheels if the opportunity arose.