This one from Car and Driver. Overall sounds about right. Our old friends the Miata and 3 series are there so it can't be all bad. Let the complaining begin.
http://autos.yahoo.com/articles/autos_content_landing_pages/1503/decade-in-review-10best-of-the-aughties/
I've always liked C & D, so I guess I'm not surprised by the picks. I find myself agreeing with most of them.
My list in no particular order:
1968 Alfa Romeo GTV, Lotus Elise, Mitsubishi Evolution VIII, 2003 Toyota MR2, Corvette C5, Porsche 993, EF Honda CRX, Genesis Coupe, Nissan 240Z, Porsche 914.
Except the Fit, I'd call that one pretty darn great. Add in the RX-8 instead.