JUst to update with my experience - I ran the online calculator on the Locton site for a declared value of 10k with $1500 deductible and it came up to $170. Taking wbjones advice, I called Lockton to see what kind of quote I could get. I spoke with Fred there and he was most helpful and courteous. He tells me the minimum they do is actually $20,000 with a $2,000 deductible and it's...$170. Basically, you can give them any value under that but you're paying the same thing. In case of an...incident...they pay up to 90% of the KBB value on the car. You can be covered for modifications that add value to the vehicle above KBB if they are documented. Basically, if I were to total the car I could try to prove to the adjuster that it was worth, say, $15,000 because of mods, but how much I could get over KBB would be up to the adjuster no matter what I bought the policy for.
That seems reasonable from the insurance company's operational point of view. You don't want some schmuck insuring his clapped out Miata for $20,000 and stuffing it in the wall on purpose. I get it.
But it puts me in a difficult spot on my car. My Mustang would have a sale price between $7,000 and $8,000 according to KBB's website. I have done some mods to it - springs, shocks, antisways, etc - but not really anything that would raise the sales price to most buyers. In the real world, we all know most mods don't actually raise resale anyway, unless they're BIG ones.
So...I could declare a value of $10,000 for my car and pay the $170, which actually means I'm getting half the coverage I'm paying for. If God forbid, something bad happens, I might only get $6500.
Granted, that's a LOT better than nothing, but also not enough to replace the car. I guess I'd feel better if I was paying $100 for a real $10k policy, even if it might have the same payoff issues? I dunno. Maybe I'm looking too deep and I should just accept that I'm effectively getting $6500 coverage for $170.
Any other recommended agencies to call? I suspect policies are similar, and I would prefer someone with as good a rep as Lockton's, but it seems unwise not to shop around.