In reply to hunter47 :
It's interesting, because I think the reverse. I can't fathom why anyone would buy an A90 Supra.
But, I'll also admit to some biases.
1) I think the A90 is one of the ugliest cars designed in the past 25 years.
2) I am not a BMW guy, at least BMWs with more than two wheels. When I say that, I mean, I have zero, absolutely zero, interest in owning a BMW or BMW-engineered vehicle. That's actually a real deal breaker for me. It wouldn't be any better if it was Mercedes, VW, or Audi engineered either. Of the Deustch only Porsche is interesting to me.
3) I'm usually biased against 'newer is better' arguments. I tend to prefer to purchase well established platforms/engine combinations, because cars are pretty expensive overall, and I am just conservative in this nature.
While I fully get the conversation when it comes to buying new and I tend to agree, buying a 2024 GT-R when there are other cars out there that have had considerable evolution, refinement, or revolution - and are cheaper - doesn't make the most sense. On the other hand, as near as I can tell, the GT-R has actually be a reliable, robust, platform since it's release and there are now millions of miles and hundreds if not thousands of modified GT-Rs running around out there to attest to this. The problems with the R35 are documented, understood, and able to be dealt with. Such is not yet the case for the A90.
For me, that clean, one or two owner 2009-2015 models, with <50k miles on them, are starting to dip down into the 60-70k range - makes them a heck of a bargain.