In reply to wbjones:
We had an incident with a prowler in the back yard early one morning, SWMBO frantically woke me, I grabbed the pistol and light from the nightstand, it was intense but dude was over the fence and gone by the time I got the back door open. I wasn't all that stealthy, and I did flip the back yard light on before opening the door which kind of tipped them off. I called the cops, they looked around, didn't seem too concerned, and that was the end of it.
Then SWMBO and I were talking, while we own a respectable number of long guns, and the one hand gun, all of the other firearms are stored away, unloaded, and generally not easy to get to them or their ammo in a timely manner, none of the bolt rifles even have bolts in them. So I basically left SWMBO unarmed in the bedroom when I took off with the pistol. This led to the decision to get a back-up home defense gun, and the age old debate of what kind, we obviously decided on a shot gun.
I'm not super brand loyal, I grew up shooting dad's 20 Ga Mossberg 500, for fun, food, and competition even, I already owned a Remington 870 Super Mag, and SWMBO has a .410 870 from her youth, so any pump action was an eligible candidate.
We looked at a lot of stuff, and needed something with a short length of pull for SWMBO to wield comfortably. We were really looking at youth models originally. Then we happened to be in Dick's while they had all their Remington shotguns on sale $100 off, including a lovely 18.5" barrel 7+1 12 Ga. 870 Tactical. All the stars aligned and it came home with us.
We had a shotgun but it was still too long for SWMBO, so I looked around, read a lot of reviews, and had her shoulder a few different options. We wound up with a Magpul SGA stock, with all of the spacers removed.
Obligatory redneck picture of firearm on a bed:
It's an 870 Tactical, Magpul SGA stock, Surefire G2X, UTG picatinny saddle, Wilson Combat Jumbo safety, Made in China mag tube quad rail and light mount, and a Leupold Deltapoint.
We're content with our decision the 870 is good, but we have added a small fortune in mods to make it great.
That doesn't make me want a .410 Judge, or Circuit Judge any less. Rossi has their Rio Grande lever gun in .410 too.