While it's not the mythological "Hudson in a warehouse", a rare, long-hidden, mostly-forgotten New York Central steam locomotive has resurfaced and is headed to the Rochester & Genesee Valley Railroad Museum. It is a 1924-built Vulcan Ironworks 0-4-0 saddle tank that belonged to Merchants Despatch Transportation. Merchants Despatch was a subsidiary of New York Central Systems from 1869 onward, and constructed, maintained and operated refrigerator cars, and later transitioned to being the main car repair facility for the New York Central. This 0-4-0 was used at the Merchants Despatch facilities in Despatch, NY (named for the company, it was later renamed to East Rochester), which turned out dozens of freight cars a day, and locomotives like these were used to move new cars to the yards for outbound delivery, bring in old cars to be repaired, and generally help move materials around the plant. In 1954, as the NYC rapidly modernized and steam was retired, the Merchants Despatch locomotives were also victims of this. MDT #5 was briefly displayed in front of the shops, but then was sold off to scrap metal dealer Rochester Iron & Metal. For many years it was displayed outside the scrap yard’s office on St. Paul Blvd.
A gentleman by the name of John Virigilio, who had taken up a job as a school custodian after a brief stint with the New York Central as a fireman and brakeman from 1949 until 1954 when diesels replaced steam, took an interest in MDT #5. His family had been collecting railroad artifacts at their farm in Henrietta for some time, with the hopes of someday opening a museum. Virgilio made inquiries with Rochester Iron & Metal about purchasing #5, but the engine was priced just beyond his reach at $3,500.
In 1964, RI&M was closing down its operation on St. Paul Blvd., and considered lowering their asking price for the engine to just $1,250. Virgilio was working as a custodian for the Rush-Henrietta school district at the time, and launched an intense fundraising effort to cover the cost of purchasing the engine. Ultimately successful, MDT #5 was moved to Henrietta by truck on June 17, 1965 and John Virgilio formed the Mortimer Railroad Historical Society, named after the junction of the New York Central, Erie, and Lehigh Valley railroads located behind his home in Henrietta. His private museum opened on June 11, 1966, and a shed was built around the steam engine in 1972 to protect it from the weather and possible vandalism. After complaints from his neighbors and concerns about the security of the collection, public viewing came to an end, and the little steam engine was tucked away and basically forgotten. MDT #5 doesn't show up on any lists of preserved steam locomotives in New York, or on any lists of surviving New York Central steam locomotives.
Virigilio passed away at the age of 91 in 2021, and his son Barry reached out to the R&GV about finding a possible home for his father’s legacy. After touring the museum, Barry and his mother Phyllis agreed that R&GV would be the perfect new home for #5, since the museum preserves the history of the Rochester area and has several MDT freight cars in their collection. The locomotive was safely delivered to Industry, NY, home of the museum, on July 7, 2023 and eventual plans are for a full cosmetic restoration.
The saddletank has been removed for asbestos remediation, and the plan is to eventually have it so that the cab is open to visitors. An operational restoration is out of the picture, due to lack of funds, facilities to service and operate a steam locomotive, and crews educated on operating a steam locomotive.