Appleseed said:
In reply to Duke :
It would appear that you and I have very different tastes in music. And that's OK. That's why music rules. If you push far enough, you will find at least one song to like together.
Of course it's OK. That's why they make more than one kind of music. I don't really know what you like, but take a cruise through the What are you listening to right now? thread to see some of the wide range of things I listen to on a daily basis. That's really a fairly incomplete sample, because I tend to post there from work, and at work I tend to listen to mostly instrumental music.
I actively enjoy classical, funk, electronica, blues (acoustic and electric), prog metal, trip hop, minimalist and experimental stuff like Sonar or Brian Eno, industrial, bluegrass, genuine country, krautrock, surf, acid jazz, post rock and neopsychedelic, sludge / doom / stoner, rockabilly, loungecore, and a whole bunch of relatively uncategorizable stuff. Where do you put Cibo Matto, for instance? I even like Vaporwave and Darkwave, for pity's sake. In a given week I will listen to all of those and more.
About the only kind of music where I cannot find a single thing to like is show tunes.
DarkMonohue said:
Minor confession: I don't dance. Never have. Never wanted to. But over the last decade or so, I have started to not hate disco. Some of it is surprisingly interesting.
I still don't get EDM.
That's a solid it depends from me. I don't like most disco, but there can be a fine line between disco (pointless dance music product) and funk (awesome danceable music) and other kinds of music that are truly danceable and were often played at discos, but avoid being disco. KC and the Sunshine Band and MFSB and The Ohio Players are all technically disco bands, but they somehow stay on the right side of the equation.
EDM has so many miniscule subgenres that it is impossible to make a blanket statement about. I'm no expert, but in general I dislike trance, house, drum-n-bass, and dubstep. Anything with that generic "BOOM tish BOOM tish BOOM tish BOOM tish BOOM tish BOOM tish" beat is just never going to do it for me. The same with that overused Oughties hyperspeed "Doot Doot DAT Doot Dootle Doot DAT" beat (say that in your head, you'll know the one I mean). That's the kind of EDM that I will never get. It's dance music that has no function or relevance outside of the actual dance floor of a packed club.
But I really like Big Beat and Chillout (there's a whole bunch of great music that can be put in this genre). I like Electro Swing from time to time. One of my favorite DJs has been described as making "sampledelic easy listening breakbeat tracks".
Streetwiseguy said:
Put me down on the "dancing is useless" side.
Not at all. I don't usually enjoy dancing myself, but I can understand the appeal. I'm just not that physical a person (I have no interest or ability in sports, either). I can't even begin to imagine expressing myself through dance like Beer Baron can, and I don't receive that emotion from watching dancers, either. Not ballet, not classical dances, not swing or ballroom. But I absolutely do NOT think dancing is useless.
I just don't like like listening to dance music as entertainment. I can't really give examples, unfortunately; it's an "I know it when I hear it" thing. Stuff they play after dinner at a typical wedding is a good start. Miami Sound Machine. C&C Music Factory. Lots and lots of modern R&B that I can't name. To dredge up some ancient history, "Funky Town" is good but "I Feel Love" is not. "I Will Survive" is good but "Ring My Bell" is not.
Does any of that help explain my original post?