A junkyard trans is a gamble, but if you're willing to gamble.....
I probably -should- have taken the trans on myself, but I really didn't think I had time. School was starting, I had a new subject to teach as well, and Mrs. Skinny needs a chariot to cart the kiddies around. I looked at my options, and in the interest of time and less gambling, I chose to "pay the man."
IF the shop had only repaired the broken trace on the valvebody and called it done, it would have been a whole lot cheaper.
BUT there was some shrapnel in the bottom of the pan, which they told me is unusual for this trans. I trust they know what they are doing, I mean they -are- a trans shop after all, and I'm not. I made the call to rebuild the trans. I could see keeping it for a while, and I had this gut feeling the trans was on its way out anyway.
AND there were, indeed, some issues with the trans once they got it apart. The clutches et al didn't look all that bad to me, but I'm not a trans guy; I really don't have that much experience.
IF the shop had put some wire under the solder to properly bridge the valvebody trace repair, it probably would have held, but it didn't look like there was any under there when I stopped by during the rebuild. Again, I'm not a trans guy, I don't do transmissions for a living. But it broke. I can see where a shop is coming from in that they don't want to gamble for a customer again to save money. Order the part, no more comeback. If I went in there myself to re-fix the solder joint, they likely wouldn't warranty the trans.
LAST NIGHT'S ISSUE was a result of low oil in the trans. Right after picking it up with the new valvebody and dealer-programming. Isn't that just awesome? There is "And I paid money for that" but there also is "we all make mistakes."
Should I have just fixed the break, and left the trans alone? Probably. I don't know. It may have lasted a good long time. It may have popped anyway. I made a choice that made sense at the time. I'm not sure, at this point, that that was the wisest choice. But I don't want my wife driving around in junk I cobbled together and hopefully doesn't fail.
Are these vehicles all that bad? No. But my epitaph is going to be "Wow, I didn't expect it to go wrong that way!"
What does scare me is that I know Nissan electrical is a bit quirky..... I'm not sure the future is going to be trouble free.
Having said all that, as soon as I sat in the Infiniti after three weeks without it, it totally feels like "home" and really did miss it. I love the car, and the first moment of sitting back in it it all seemed worth it ("Because I'm stupid" - my other Epitaph).