We got back Friday night, well around 1:00 AM Saturday morning actually, storms kept us circling the air port for a while, so our late flight, was even later.
We rented a Chevy Sonic LTZ from Hertz, so we had transportation. Learned that I don't want to own a Chevy Sonic, but it was a tolerable appliance, and suited our needs for the week just fine.
We stayed at The Lodge, Autograph Collection at Williamsburg, it was a nice place, and only about a block south of Colonial Williamsburg, so a pretty convenient location.
Colonial Williamsburg was really neat, but we weren't prepared for the size of the place, it's huge! We spent roughly 2 days there. We did most of the guided tours they offered, nerded out on history, asked the wheelwright, joiner, blacksmith, carpenter/furniture shops, and all of the kitchen reenactors a million questions each. We had the best interpreters/docents there, especially at the capitol. We ate lunch at Josiah Chowing's Tavern in Colonial Willamsburg one day too, pretty good grub.
We did the whole "Historic Triangle," so we spent a full day at Jamestown, and Yorktown too. We learned, and re-learned a lot that we'd forgotten.
We also took a little road trip to Monticello on our last day. As tempting as the news made the Charolettesville riots sound, we still avoided them. Monticello was pretty amazing, we had to have our rental car back about 2 hours before our flight, so we didn't get to spend as much time at Monticello as we'd have liked, but did get to tour the house, and gardens.
1988RedT2 & bludroptop, we went to Williamsburg Pottery, it was not what we expected, it was more of a Bed Bath & Beyond meets Pier One, nick knacks, and E36 M3ty home decor, with a little bit of cookware, and a tiny little bit of pottery. I had to ask a lady that worked there where the pottery was, she informed me that they hadn't actually made any pottery in over 2 years, so they didn't have much left. That is one huge strip mall though, granted it was 3 in the afternoon on a Thursday, but there were only a handful of patrons there, I was wondering how they pay to keep the lights on?
We really didn't eat that much, coffee and a pastry in the morning, and a late lunch was a typical day. We took several of your suggestions. First night we ate at 2nd Street Bistro, it was a Zomato recommendation, and was pretty good. We had a meal at DoG Street that was good, and went to Captain George's on the Hertz guy's recommendation. Captain Geroge's was okay, I probably wouldn't go back, we didn't know it was a buffet until we got there, we did not get our moneys worth. One night we just got a chocolates and truffles from Wythe Candy Shop, and a cheese tray from the Cheese Shop in Williamsburg, and that was our meal. Otherwise, we just grabbed a sandwich at the cafe of whatever museum we happened to be in at the time.
We didn't go to any of the breweries or wineries, but I did try a couple different Alewerks beers at a couple of restaurants most were good, and Jewels tried a few Virginia wines that she liked. I'm a sucker for Yuengling too, and since we can't get it in AR, I indulged, and even brought a 6 pack back to the hotel with me.
We had a great time, and really appreciate everyone's suggestions, thanks!