Car Review Time!
Two years ago today, I traded in my disappointingly falling-apart-at-61K-miles 2009 WRX on a 2012 Mazda 3 S Touring 5-door in Crystal White Pearl Mica equipped with the 2.5L MZR engine and a 6-speed manual transmission. I was not looking forward to the 100 horsepower difference between the two cars, but as a trade-off, I had high hopes for better dependability and better gas mileage for my long daily commute. I wanted something that was still going to be fun to drive, and I wanted a few creature comforts like Bluetooth, a decent stereo, and a moon roof, and I was familiar with the 3 because my wife had bought a 2010 sedan earlier in the year.
I narrowed down the playing field to three cars in that segment: the 2012 Focus, the 2012 Civic Si sedan, and the 2012 Mazda 3. I couldn't stand late model Toyotas, I didn't like the Chevy Cruze's styling at all, we just came off a really bad experience with a Hyundai Elantra so they were out, and I had already gone down the path of disappointment with a VW 10 years earlier and wasn't ready to switch to a diesel.
The 2012 Focus was initially not available with many creature comforts if you wanted a stick, and I hated the Power Shift automatic after test driving a Fiesta with the transmission when my wife was car shopping. They later corrected this by offering a SE Sport package, but when I was shopping, it wasn't available yet.
The Civic Si was my main benchmark. A friend had one, and after driving it, I wanted one. Unfortunately, the 2012 Civic Si was backordered due to the Japanese Tsunami, and the few that trickled in were marked up because of "adjusted market value". I would have considered a 2011, but there were none left on any local dealer lots. Used and abused ones were going for the price the new ones were supposed to be.
I also considered the Mazdaspeed 3. I really wanted one, but I decided against it because I wanted something simple to maintain and something that took cheap gas for once after diving two WRX's for the past 6 years.
So, two years later, here I am with my 3. The car has nearly 51,000 miles on the clock now . How has it held up?
Pros:
-The car has been very reliable. It starts every day and gets me to where I need to go. I bought a set of snow tires on steel wheels early on, and the car is great in the winter with them, rivaling the snow traction of my WRX's. AWD is nice, but you don't need it.
-Gas mileage and general cost of running this car has been better than expected. My lifetime MPG average is around 27.4 mpg, and the car is rated 20 city/28 highway. I've gotten upwards of 33 MPG a few times on long trips. The worst I've gotten was 23, and that was over last winter after getting hit by a blizzard, and my car was idling to charge my cell phone as well as to melt some of the snow while clearing the driveway. Not as good as the Skyactiv cars, but better than my one time best of 25 MPG in the WRX.
-Maintenance has been VERY simple and cheap so far. Oil changes are due every 7500 miles running 0W20 Mobil 1 synthetic. There's no stupid splash shields in the way to remove; they have holes in the shield for oil filter access. It hasn't burned a drop of oil. I've done an air filter and the cabin air filters, and those were pretty easy.
-It still handles great. I want to say that it handles better than my 2009 WRX did, even with it's fatter wheels (I was running 17x8's with 245/40/17's) and larger rear bar. It's way more tossable, and the steering feel is great. The car is still very fun to drive. I may make it to an autocross event next season with it if my CSX isn't ready yet. It's a blast to drive in the twisties, and probably the best handling and most balanced FWD car I've driven.
-The factory shifter is worlds better than the WRX was, even after I upgraded it with a Kartboy setup with all the poly bushings. I did upgrade the rear engine mount to a solid polyurethane Torque Solutions mount, which makes shifting even better, but it rattles your teeth a bit. I may remove it.
-The stereo sounds great and the Bluetooth rules. I won't buy a daily driver without it here on out. Streaming music from my phone is cool, and hands-free talking is a lot less distracting.
-The interior is a lot nicer than the one out of either one of my WRX's. The dash is not all hard plastic, and the gauges are decent. The info display on the dash and many of the controls are driver-oriented, which I like. Mine has small blue LED's here and there that light up at night and illuminate certain areas on the car, such as one on the ceiling that illuminates the shifter and console, which is a subtle and cool touch. I really like the sliding center armrest, which lets you shift with your fingertips when resting your arm on it.
-I actually like the looks. I've surprisingly gotten many compliments from complete strangers on the car. The 2012 models have a revised front fascia that negates a bit of the goofiness of the 2010-11 cars. My wife's car looks like it's a buck-toothed cartoon character wearing braces. Mine? Not as much. And the Crystal White Pearl Mica color looks awesome. It was my first non-silver car in a long time, and I think I made the right choice. I even like the funky directional wheels. See?
Cons:
-It's still an econobox. I like the interior, but it's developed some rattles over the past two years. I will say that the WRX was more rattly at 20k than this car is at 50K+.
-The seats could be a little more comfortable. The driver's seat has something going on with it where it clunks a bit going around some corners, but I can't find the source. My wife's car does it too. The bolts are tight, so I have no clue.
-The steering wheel could be better. I think the diameter is perfect, but the thickness of the rim could be a bit more, and could use hand grips like most other sporty cars have. I mean, come on Mazda: if a 1990's Cavalier can have a 3-spoke wheel with hand grips, you guys could do it on this car.
-The clutch and transmission. This is a common complaint on these cars. The clutch action is light, which is fine, but it's almost digital in engagement. I'm used to it now, but I remember it taking a few weeks to nail it down. The transmission has an intermittent problem grinding from 1st to 2nd, and from what I read, it could be resolved by changing the transmission fluid. It started doing it around 35K or so, but I've noticed that if I shift slower, it doesn't happen as much. The fluid's getting changed before winter.
-The stock Yokohama Avid S04 (or whatever they are) tires are terrible. This can be said for just about any car though, so I really can't hold this against it. I can't wait to put better tires on the car.
-I wish I could hear the engine more. It's a cool sounding engine, and I wish they made it so you could hear it a bit like you can on other sporty econocars like the Civic Si.
Overall, I still feel like I made the right choice. Yes, I'd buy another one, but I'd probably sacrifice the 10hp and get the Skyactiv version. It's been a great car, and although not perfect, it has surpassed my expectations. I highly recommend them if you are looking for a cheap to maintain and fun to drive econobox.
C/N: 2012 Mazda 3's are good cars.