I'm driving my wife's convertible today. Drove it all last week.
It's an autotragic, but other than that, it's quite fun little car to drive. Granted, my DD is a Tahoe right now, so anything that isn't heavy enough to have it's own gravity field would probably be fun. I had a MINI Cooper (non-S) for 6 years and it's comparable. The MINI felt more sure footed, but I've yet to feel like I'm going to lose it in the 500. It sways a bit more, but seems just as planted.
With the auto, around 31-31 in town, 34 on the highway. I get about 25 in town when I drive it.
The engine is just a smidge too small which results in me winding it out to keep up with traffic. Fun to do, but MPG suffers.
You'll probably drive with Sport mode on 99% of the time (the other 1% is when you'll forget to turn it on.) There IS a difference and it just feels better.
No major issues at this point. Some slight interior trim things and a little seat squeak, but not horrible. Yet....
Like:
1) Fun to drive. Definitely the "drive a slow car fast" mentality.
2) Handles well and easy to point and shoot.
3) Even for a 275 lb 5'11" me, I fit just fine.
4) Life does not suck driving it.....
Bad:
1) Autotragic (although it's slap shifting in sport mode is surprisingly quick and it'll even downshift.) Obviously, anyone on this board would not have checked that option.
2) Engine is peppy and likes to rev, which is good considering you need to do that on a regular basis to merge with traffic
3) Seats need to be about 1/2" lower. My head doesn't hit the roof, but you definitely feel like you're sitting up high. If it was mine, I'd probably figure out how to lower it, but since it's the wife's and she's happy with it....
4) Front seat flip down handle sucks!! Pushing the seat back while lifting helps, but I'm just waiting for the day the handle breaks
Overall, I really like it an have my name on the list for an Abarth version.
-Rob