Behind a small buffer of woods sat an old farmhouse. No one seemed to know anything about it, but you'd hear some activity–like the occasional tractor.
But we were kids, so what did we care about an old farmhouse located a few hundred yards away from us? It was alllll the way around the corner, so it might as well have been on another planet. But from the road, yeah, it looked bleak: untreated siding, hollow windows, unkept yard.
Through the magic of the internet, a little while back I started to research that farmhouse. What stories did it have to tell?
Well, the house was built in the 1750s, with the house I grew up in–as well as all of the ones around us–built on their old farmland.
But the farmhouse also saw a grisly double homicide!
The husband and wife who lived there were attacked with a hammer or such heavy object.
From the deposition:
“Alexander lay with his head from the fire place, his body was chiefly consumed up to his 3rd or 4th rib.”
Sounds like he was struck and then fell into the fire, which then burned him up.
About his wife: "Mrs. Smith was lying in the right corner of the fireplace; her head at the corner of the hearth… her dress was bloody down to her waist…She seems from appearances to have struggled. There was blood in the middle of the floor, and spread to the place where she lay."
I recently asked my mom: How come no one ever told us about this!?
My mom had no idea.
The murders took place in 1842.